CHARACTERIZING A BRAIN TUMOR
CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS
The present application claims the benefit of U.S. provisional application serial number 60/215,623 filed June 30, 2000.
STATEMENT AS TO FEDERALLY SPONSORED RESEARCH
This invention was made with Government support under grant number
R01 CA74145 awarded by the Public Health Service. The Government may have certain rights in the invention.
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
The invention relates generally to the fields of pathology, medicine, and neuro- oncology. More particularly, the invention relates to the use of interleukin-13 (IL-13) binding
as a marker for diagnosing the type and/or grade of a brain tumor, and for assessing the
prognosis of a patient having a brain tumor.
BACKGROUND
The identification of tumor-associated cellular markers has proven useful for
diagnosing various tumors and assessing the prognosis of patients with tumors. Cellular
markers that occur on the plasma membrane or in a membrane receptor are particularly
useful. Antibodies specific for tumor cell markers or ligands that bind specifically to a tumor cell receptor have been successfully used in diagnostics, including both the characterization
of excised tissue samples and in vivo imaging.
Numerous different brain tumors are known. For example, several types of brain tumors known as gliomas originate from glial tissue. Within this set of tumors are
astrocytomas, brain stem gliomas, ependymomas, and oligodendogliomas. Astrocytomas
originate from star-shaped cells termed astrocytes; brain stem gliomas originate in the brain stem; ependymomas originate in the lining of the ventricles or spinal cord; and
oligodendrogliomas arise from myelin-producing cells. Brain tumors may also be of non-
glial origin. Such non-glial tumors include medulloblastomas, meningiomas, Schwannomas,
craniopharyngiomas, germ cell tumors, pineal region tumors, and secondary brain tumors.
Brain tumors are often referred to by grade (grades I-IV), a subjective categorization
of a tumor based on the microscopic appearance of its cells. The cells of a high grade tumor
(e.g., grade IV) have a more abnormal appearance than cells of a low grade (e.g., grade I)
tumor. Cells from grade II and grade III tumors have an appearance intermediate between
grades I and IV. Tumors are accorded a grade in order to provide an objective measurement of the seriousness of the disease in a patient with the tumor. Higher grade tumors are generally more malignant, while lower grade tumors are generally less malignant. For
example, a grade I astrocytoma is less malignant than a grade II astrocytoma which is less
malignant than a grade III (or anaplastic) astrocytoma. The most malignant astrocytoma is a grade IV astrocytoma also known as glioblastoma multiforme (GBM).
It is important to know the type and grade of tumor a patient is suffering from in order
to decide the most appropriate treatment to the patient. For example, high grade gliomas such
as anaplastic astrocytomas and GBMs grow quickly and infiltrate surrounding tissue easily. In comparison, meningiomas grow much more slowly and with less infiltration. Because of these characteristics, anaplastic astrocytomas and GBMs typically demand more immediate and aggressive treatment than do meningiomas. Thus, methods for determining the type and
grade of a brain tumor provide information that is often critical in selecting a course of treatment.
Conventionally, brain tumors are diagnosed by imaging. For example, brain tumors
can be detected in situ as abnormal growths by angiography, computerized tomography,
and/or magnetic resonance imaging. In some cases, the information provided by imaging
may be inadequate to determine the type and/or grade of brain tumor a patient has. To further
characterize a brain tumor, the tumor may be biopsied so that a trained pathologist can microscopically examine a section of the biopsied sample to determine the type and grade of
the tumor. Such a histopathological examination involves a certain degree of subjectivity on
the part of the pathologist. While certain types of tumors may be clearly distinguishable
based on microscopic appearance, other are less so. For example, while the prognosis of a patient suffering from a high grade astrocytoma may be much more bleak than that of a
patient suffering from a low grade astrocytoma, the histopathological appearance of biopsy samples from the two grades of tumors may be difficult to differentiate and dependent on
subjective judgment.
Complicating this, low grade tumors may progress to high grade tumors.
Unfortunately, conventional histopathology techniques often do not provide definitive guidance as to which low grade tumors will progress to high grade and which will not.
Thus new methods for differentiating brain tumor types and grades and for providing
guidance as to which low grade tumors will progress to high grade would be valuable for
assessing the prognosis of a brain tumor, and for determining the most appropriate course of treatment for a brain tumor patient.
SUMMARY
The invention relates to the discovery that interleukin-13 (IL-13) binding can be used to characterize and distinguish among different types and grades of brain tumors. In the
experiments described herein, almost all surgical specimens of a series of 20 human
glioblastoma multiformes (GBMs) were determined to over-express specific binding sites for 125I-labeled human IL-13 (hIL-13) in situ. This was confirmed in other experiments on samples from over 60 GBMs, where the vast majority of GBMs showed specific binding of
labeled IL-13. In comparison, low-grade gliomas (grades I and II) were found to express IL-
13 binding sites much more sporadically than did grade III or IV gliomas. Thus, this new
finding suggests that the appearance of detectable binding sites for IL-13 accompanies the
progression of low- to high-grade gliomas.
IL-13 binding was also assessed in other gliomas and in non-glial origin brain tumors. In these studies, oligodendrogliomas were found to express IL-13 binding sites when the
tumor was anaplastic. Surprisingly, pilocytic astrocytomas were also found to possess IL-13
binding sites. In contrast, IL-13 receptor expression was not detected in the non-glial origin brain tumors examined, including secondary brain tumors (metastases) and those tumors of
neural or mesodermal origin. Based on the foregoing, the present discovery provides
methods and compositions for diagnosing the type and or grade of a brain tumor, and for
assessing the prognosis of a patient having a brain tumor.
Accordingly, in one aspect the invention features a method of classifying a brain
tumor by type or grade. This method includes the steps of: (a) providing a brain tumor sample; (b) quantifying the expression of an IL-13 receptor in the sample; and (c) correlating
the quantity of expression of the IL-13 receptor on the sample with a tumor type or rumor
grade. In this method, the step of correlating the quantity of expression of the IL-13 receptor
on the sample with a characteristic of the tumor can be performed by comparing the amount of IL-13 receptor expressed on the sample with the amount of IL-13 receptor expressed on a
second brain tumor sample that has previously been characterized by type and grade.
The invention also features a method of distinguishing a higher-grade brain tumor
from a lower-grade brain tumor. This method includes the steps of: providing a brain tumor sample; quantifying the expression of an IL-13 receptor in the sample; and correlating the
quantity of expression of the IL-13 receptor on the sample with the grade of the tumor.
Higher expression of the IL-13 receptor on the sample indicates increased likelihood that the
tumor is a higher grade brain tumor, and lower expression of the IL-13 receptor on the sample
indicates increased likelihood that the rumor is a lower grade brain tumor.
Also within the invention is a method of analyzing the prognosis of subject with a
brain tumor. This method includes the steps of: (a) providing a sample of tissue isolated from
a brain tumor in the subject; (b) quantifying the expression of an IL-13 receptor in the sample; and (c) correlating the quantity of expression of the IL-13 receptor on the sample with the prognosis of the tumor in the subject. Higher expression of the IL-13 receptor on the
sample correlates with increased likelihood of a poor prognosis, and lower expression of the
IL-13 receptor on the sample correlates with decreased likelihood of a poor prognosis.
In the methods of the invention, the IL-13 receptor can be the restrictive form of IL-13
receptor that does not specifically bind IL-4. Additionally, the step of providing the brain
tumor sample can include surgically removing at least a portion of a brain tumor from a
human patient. The step of quantifying the expression of an IL-13 receptor in the sample can
performed by contacting the sample with a probe that specifically binds an IL-13 receptor and then measuring the amount of the probe that binds the sample. The probe can be, e.g., IL-13 (e.g., human IL-13), a fragment of IL-13 that specifically binds the IL-13 receptor, a mutant
form of IL-13 that specifically binds the IL-13 receptor, or an antibody that specifically binds
the IL-13 receptor. The probe can be conjugated with a detectable label such as a radioactive
label, an enzyme, a fluorescent label, or a radio-opaque label.
In another aspect, the invention features a kit for classifying a brain tumor by type or
grade. The kit includes a probe that specifically binds an IL-13 receptor; and instructions for using the kit to classify a brain tumor by type or grade.
As used herein, "bind," "binds," or "interacts with" means that one molecule
recognizes and adheres to a particular second molecule in a sample, but does not substantially recognize or adhere to other structurally unrelated molecules in the sample. Generally, a first
molecule that "specifically binds" a second molecule has a binding affinity greater than about
105 to 106 liters/mole for that second molecule.
By the term "antibody" is meant any antigen-binding peptide derived from an
immunoglobulin. The term includes polyclonal antisera, monoclonal antibodies, fragments of immunoglobulins produced by enzymatic digestion (e.g., Fab fragments) or genetic
engineering (e.g., sFv fragments).
When referring to a protein, the term "mutant" means a modified version of the native
protein. A native protein is one found in nature. A protein may be modified by amino acid substitution, deletion, addition, permutation (e.g., circular permutation), etc. "Functional"
mutants retain a biological characteristic of the native protein (e.g., the capability of binding
of a ligand or producing an enzymatic activity), whereas "non- functional" mutants have lost a
biological characteristic.
Unless otherwise defined, all technical terms used herein have the same meaning as commonly understood by one of ordinary skill in the art to which this invention belongs. Although methods and materials similar or equivalent to those described herein can be used
in the practice or testing of the present invention, suitable methods and materials are described below. All publications, patent applications, patents, and other references
mentioned herein are incorporated by reference in their entirety. In the case of conflict, the present specification, including definitions will control. In addition, the particular
embodiments discussed below are illustrative only and not intended to be limiting.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
The invention encompasses compositions and methods for diagnosing the type and/or
grade of a brain tumor, and for assessing the prognosis of a patient having a brain tumor. The
below described preferred embodiments illustrate adaptations of these compositions and
methods. Nonetheless, from the description of these embodiments, other aspects of the invention can be made and/or practiced based on the description provided below.
Biological Methods
Methods involving conventional biological techniques are described herein. Such
techniques are generally known in the art and are described in detail in various methodology
treatises. For example, molecular biology techniques are described in Molecular Cloning: A Laboratory Manual, 2nd ed., vol. 1-3, ed. Sambrook et al., Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
Press, Cold Spring Harbor, N.Y., 1989; and Current Protocols in Molecular Biology, ed.
Ausubel et al., Greene Publishing and Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1992 (with periodic
updates). Immunological methods (e.g., preparation of antigen-specific antibodies, immunoprecipitation, and immunoblotting) are described, e.g., in Current Protocols in
Immunology, ed. Coligan et al., John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1991; and Methods of
Immunological Analysis, ed. Masseyeff et al., John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1992.
Brain Tumor Samples
Methods within the invention include a step of providing a sample of tissue isolated
from a brain tumor in a subject. The subject from which the sample is taken will generally be
a patient having a brain tumor, although the subject can also be a non-human animal such as a
mammal (e.g., dogs, cats, goats, sheep, cows, horses, etc.) having a brain tumor. For laboratory experiments, the subject may be an animal (e.g., a rodent such as an athymic or SCID mouse or rat) into which a tumor has been created such as by xenografting human brain
tumor cells. A sample of the tumor can be isolated from a subject by any conventional
means. For example, a biopsy of a brain tumor in a human patient can be obtained by
known surgical methods. See e.g., Greenberg, M., Handbook of Neurosurgery 5th Ed.,
Thieme Medical Pub., 2000; Lindsay K. and I. Bone, Neurology and Neurosurgery
Illustrated 3rd Ed., Churchill Livingstone, 1997.
Quantifying the Expression of an IL-13 Receptor in a Sample
Methods of the invention also include a step of quantifying the expression of an IL-13 receptor on a brain tumor tissue sample. Numerous methods for characterizing receptor
expression on a cell or tissue sample are known. Typically, these methods employ a probe
that specifically binds the receptor of interest. The cell or sample is contacted with the probe
under conditions that allow the probe to specifically bind to any of the particular receptors on
the cells or tissue. Binding of the probe is then quantified as an indication of the amount of receptor on the cells or tissue. To facilitate this, the probe can feature a detectable label such as a radioactive, enzymatic, fluorescent, or radio-opaque (e.g., gold particle) label.
Preferred examples of probes that can be used to quantify IL-13 receptor expression include IL-13 itself (or fragments or mutants thereof that retain the ability to specifically bind
the IL-13 receptor) and antibodies (e.g., monoclonal or polyclonal antibodies or fragments thereof) that specifically bind an IL-13 receptor. As "shared" receptors that bind both IL-13
and interleukin 4 (IL-4) are known, a particularly preferred probe is one that detects an IL-13
receptor that does not bind IL-4 (i.e., an IL-13 restrictive receptor), e.g., the IL-13 receptor
alpha2 chain. Several mutants of IL-13 that bind the IL-13 restrictive receptor but not the shared receptor are known. See, e.g., International Patent Application Number WOO 125282. In addition, where IL-13 is used as a probe, to prevent undesired binding to a shared receptor,
the cells or samples being analyzed can be pre-incubated with unlabeled IL-4 as described in
U.S. patent application serial number 08/706,207.
Any suitable method for quantifying the amount of a receptor in a sample may be used in the invention. Well known conventional methods that use a probe that binds to a protein
receptor include: immunohistochemistry, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA),
radioimmunoassay (RIA), direct or indirect immunofluoroscence analysis (e.g., fluorescence
microscopy or flow cytometry), and Western blotting. For tissue sections, a preferred method for quantifying the amount of IL-13 receptor in the sample includes the steps of contacting a tissue section with a radiolabeled probe that specifically binds an IL-13 receptor (e.g., 125-1
labeled IL-13), and then measuring the amount of radioactivity associated with the section,
e.g., by autoradiography. For cells in solution, a preferred method for quantifying the
amount of IL-13 receptor in the sample is direct or indirect immunofluoroscence analysis using either a fluorescently labeled antibody that binds an IL-13 receptor, or fluorescently
labeled IL-13. For tissue or cells that may be damaged, preferred methods for quantifying
the amount of IL-13 receptor in the sample are Western blotting, ELISA, and RIA.
In some cases, the amount of IL-13 expressed by a cell or tissue sample can be approximated by measuring the amount of mRNA encoding an IL-13 receptor in the sample.
Numerous methods for measuring the amount of mRNA in a cell or tissue sample are known. For example, quantitative PCR analysis or Northern blotting could be used.
Correlating the Quantity of IL-13 receptor Expression with the Type and Grade of Tumor.
Various methods of the invention include a step of correlating the amount of IL-13
receptor on a cell or tissue sample with the type and/or grade of tumor that the sample was
isolated from. Typing and grading of brain tumors is described, e.g., in Fletcher, D.M.,
Diagnostic Histopathology of Tumors 2nd Ed., Churchill Livingstone, 2000; and McLendon et al., Pathology of Tumors of the Central Nervous System: A Guide to Histologic Diagnosis,
Edward Arnold, 2000. As set forth below in the Examples section, certain types and grades
of brain tumors are characterized by certain levels of IL-13 receptor expression (as measured
by IL-13 binding). For example, most GBMs and grade III gliomas bind IL-13, whereas little
or no IL-13 binding was present in low grade gliomas, medulloblastomas or meningiomas. Thus, among glial-derived tumors, higher expression of the IL-13 receptor on the sample appears to correlate with increased likelihood that the tumor is a higher grade brain tumor,
while lower expression of the receptor correlates with increased likelihood that the tumor is a
lower grade brain tumor.
Based on the foregoing, the invention also provides a method of correlating the
quantity of IL-13 receptor expression on a sample of a brain tumor with the prognosis of the
subject with the tumor. For example, for gliomas, in some cases, higher expression of the IL-
13 receptor on the sample generally will correlate with a poor prognosis of the patient, while
lower expression will correlate with a better prognosis.
Kits
The invention also provides kits for diagnosing the type and/or grade of a brain tumor.
The kit includes a probe that specifically binds to an IL-13 receptor, a means for detecting the probe (e.g., a detectable label that is associated with the probe or can be caused to bind the
probe), and printed instructions for using the kit. The kit can also include other components
to assist in quantifying the amount of IL-13 receptor expression in a sample. Such other
components might include a substrate to which the cell or tissue sample can be immobilized, e.g., a glass slide or a microtiter plate; or reagents for visualizing the detectable label.
Examples
Exemplary methods and compositions that illustrate several aspects of the invention
are described below (see also Debinski et al., J. Neuro-Oncol. 48:103, 2000).
Example 1 -Materials and Methods
Production and purification of recombinant proteins. E. coli BL21 (λDE3) cells were
transformed with plasmids of interest and cultured in LB Broth (GIBCO/Life Technologies). Procedures for recombinant protein isolation and purification have been previously described
(Debinski et al., J. Biol. Chem. 270: 16775-16780, 1995; Debinski et al., Nature Biotech.
16: 449-453, 1998).
Autoradiography. Recombinant hIL-13, EGF, and monoclonal antibody (MAb) HB21
were labeled with 125I by using the IODO-GEN reagent (Pierce) according to the manufacturer's instructions. Brain tumor samples were obtained from patients undergoing surgical decompression at Perm State University and University of Alabama at Birmingham
Medical Centers. There were 82 patients evaluated in this study, with 41 females and 37
males, age 1 to 81 years (4 without gender identification). Serial tissue sections were cut (10
μm) on a cryostat, thaw-mounted on chrome-alum coated slides, and stored at -80°C until
analyzed (Debinski et al., Clin. Cancer Res. 5: 985-990, 1999). To observe binding
distribution of 125I-ligands, sections were incubated exactly as described (id.). After drying,
labeled sections were apposed to Kodak autoradiography film at -70 °C for 1 to 3 days on average. For autoradiography on cultured cells, 5x104 cells were placed on a sterile glass slide in a small volume of media and allowed to attach. The cells were maintained overnight at 37
°C. The slides were then washed in two changes of 0.1 M PBS and fixed with ethanol. The
slides were rinsed again with 0.1 M PBS and processed for autoradiography.
Autoradiographic images were scanned using Agfa's Arcus II scanner (Ridgefield Park, NJ) at 675 pixels/in2. The images were processed using Paint Shop Pro JASC Software
(Minnetonka, MN).
Example 2-Results
Low-grade glioma tissue staining. To demonstrate the presence of binding sites for IL-13, EGF, and Tf in clinical specimens of brain tumors in situ, autoradiographic analysis
using appropriate radiolabeled ligands in tissues derived primarily from GBM patients was
performed (Debinski et al., Clin. Cancer Res. 5: 985-990, 1999; Debinski et al, Int. J.
Oncol. 15:481, 1999). These studies provided evidence for the presence of IL-4-independent binding sites for IL-13 in a vast majority of patients with GBM. Binding sites of this
characteristic were also found on a majority of established GBM cell lines (Debinski et al, J. Biol. Chem. 271:428, 1996). To further analyze phenotypic appearance of other than high-
grade gliomas with regard to the expression of IL-13 binding sites, autoradiography was
performed on samples of multiple brain tumors using 125I-radiolabeled IL-13, EGF, and a
monoclonal antibody against human transferrin receptor (TfR), HB21. The study was
designed to be done on same-patient contiguous tissue sections of the same piece of tumor,
whenever possible, for all the ligands.
Eleven low-grade gliomas showed little evidence for 125I-hIL-13 specific binding by
most of the samples. Only fibrillary low-grade glioma and two grade II samples showed signs of radiolabeled IL-13 specific binding to various degrees. This binding, of interest, was
mainly IL-4-independent as an excess of unlabeled hIL-13, and not IL-4, competed for the
binding of 125I-hIL-13 in those tumor specimens. Also, a minority of the low-grade glioma
studied expressed EGF binding sites, however, the sample of mixed oligo #14 was extremely
enriched in this receptor. The binding sites for anti-transferrin receptor antibody, HB21, were
present uniformly among low-grade gliomas, although the intensity of the binding was
relatively low. Thus, only 3/11 low-grade gliomas exhibited IL-4-independent binding sites
for IL-13.
High-grade glioma tissue staining. Demonstrating that low-grade gliomas are only sporadic expressors of IL-13 binding sites, further high-grade glioma specimens were
analyzed. Autoradiography was performed on five available specimens of grade III
astrocytomas. All showed clearly positive binding of radiolabeled IL-13. Except for one
specimen, this binding was mostly IL-4-independent. In addition to this group of grade III astrocytomas, autoradiography was performed on another group of 20 new specimens of grade
IV astrocytomas (i.e., GBMs). GBM bound radiolabeled IL-13 uniformly and mainly in an
IL-4-independent manner. Specimens of 3 recurrent GBMs showed a similar pattern of IL-13
binding. In other experiments on more than 40 tissue specimens of GBM similar IL-13- binding results were obtained. Thus, there is a profound difference between low- and high- grade gliomas in terms of the presence of significant amounts of IL-13 binding sites. Only a
small subgroup of low-grade gliomas over-express IL-13 binding sites while high-grade glioma ubiquitously demonstrate high expression levels of these sites.
Other than low- or high-grade glioma astrocytic tumors staining. In addition to the
foregoing, several other forms of astrocytomas, such as oligodendrogliomas, ependymomas,
and pilocytic astrocytomas were examined. Among oligodendrogliomas, an anaplastic form
of these tumors showed readily positive staining for 125I-IL-13 and those binding sites proved to be IL-4-independent. However, the presence of IL-13 binding was not detected in two
samples of differentiated oligodendrogliomas. Ependymomas also appeared to be
phenotypically silent for IL-13 binding. In a very unexpected development, all six pilocytic
astrocytomas tested exhibited a clear-cut presence of IL-13 binding sites of a restrictive in
character, i.e. IL-4-independent.
Binding of IL-13 to brain tumors of other than glial origin. None of the four
medulloblastoma brain tissue samples and one ganglioglioma tested showed appreciable affinity for 125I-hIL-13. The examined tissues showed variable retention of 125I-hIL-13, which
was not changed in the presence of an excess of hIL-13. However, the DAOY
medulloblastoma cell line obtained from ATCC bound 125I-IL-13 very densely and specifically
for IL-13, and not for IL-4- a result in line with the previous observation that DAOY cells are
extremely responsive to the IL-13 -based cytotoxins. Neither medulloblastomas nor
gangliogliomas demonstrated significant specific 125I-EGF binding. However, the receptor
for transferrin was present in all the samples tested. Among other brain tumors, two
gliosarcomas were positive for an IL-4-independent receptor for IL-13, but not acoustic neuroma, choroid plexus papilloma, or rhabdomyosarcoma.
The lack of IL-13 receptors in meningiomas. 20 meningiomas were subjected to autoradiographic analysis. Only two specimens out of 20 showed positivity for IL-13 binding
sites. However, at least seven meningioma samples stained for EGFR and practically all of them showed the presence of transferrin receptor. Thus, the binding sites for IL-13 are absent
among meningiomas.
Metastases to brain and IL-13 binding. 12 brain tumors, identified as metastases to the
brain, were obtained. Only four tumor samples showed binding sites for I 5I-hIL-13. Three of
these were adenocarcinomas originating from the lung, and one was a renal cell carcinoma. A similar percentage of studied metastases (4/12) showed detectable binding for EGF. Again, the pattern of staining for the TfR by radiolabeled antibody HB21 was comparable to other
brain tumors, i.e. it was present in virtually all tumors with differing degree of its density.
Other Embodiments
This description has been by way of example of how the compositions and methods of invention can be made and carried out. Those of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that
various details may be modified in arriving at the other detailed embodiments, and that many
of these embodiments will come within the scope of the invention. Therefore, to apprise the
public of the scope of the invention and the embodiments covered by the invention, the following claims are made.
What is claimed is: