SUBTRACTIVE ANTIBODY SCREENING (SAS) AND USES THEREFOR
FUNDING
Work described herein was funded in whole or in part by Grant Numbers DK 47618 and DK 02219 from the National Institutes of Health. Accordingly, the United States Government has certain rights in the invention.
RELATED APPLICATION
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Serial number 60/035,371, entitled Subtractive Antibody Screening (SAS) and Uses Therefor, by Perry E. Bickel, Philipp E. Scherer and Harvey F. Lodish, filed January 9, 1997. The
teachings of U.S. Serial number 60/035,371 are incorporated expressly herein by reference.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
The ability to identify and clone genes expressed in specific tissues and disease states has great value for drug discovery and development of diagnostic tools. To date, strategies that address this critical goal are limited. Typical cDNA expression libraries and screening methods are limited because they are dependent upon the different levels of messenger RNA encoding specific proteins. Unfortunately, the genes of interest are not always represented by high levels of corresponding RNA. Proteins of interest are often those expressed in a tissue specific or disease state specific manner. Attempts to improve the likelihood of obtaining differentially expressed genes involve generation of subtractive cDNA libraries, whereby the cDNAs common between two or more cell types are removed from the library. This method is also limited by the relative abundance of specific mRNA molecules encoding proteins of interest. Messenger RNA expression may not adequately represent the proteins of greatest interest.
Furthermore, the preceding methods do not promote the cloning of genes encoding proteins localized in specific subcellular compartments of a cell (e.g. nuclear, cytoplasmic, organellar, plasma membrane, intracellular membrane or secretory proteins) . In particular, plasma membrane and secretory proteins are of great interest as potential drug targets.
Specialized cDNA libraries have been constructed (U.S. Patent 5,536,637) that promote the cloning of genes encoding secretory proteins that possess a signal sequence, whereby the cDNA is ligated to DNA encoding a non-secreted yeast invertase. Those constructs which subsequently allow invertase auxotrophic yeast to proliferate on sucrose medium are selected. Thus, genes possessing a signal sequence may be cloned. However, not all genes of interest possess a signal sequence, even of those genes encoding plasma membrane proteins. For example, type II plasma membrane proteins (whose c-terminus is extracellular) do not possess a typical signal sequence.
Further, the process of cloning and characterizing a novel gene and encoded protein is a time consuming and labor intensive process. Once it is determined that a sequence is novel, laborious characterization is necessary to determine whether the gene and encoded protein are of interest or are potential drug candidates based on expression pattern and response to stimuli. In order to accomplish these goals, antibodies specific for the novel protein are useful to characterize, purify, monitor and manipulate the novel protein. The methods described thus far do not facilitate such processes in any way.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION Described herein is a method of identifying and isolating proteins of interest that are expressed in a particular cell type or tissue type, and not expressed in at least one other cell type or tissue type (the subtractive cell type or tissue type) . Also described herein is a method of identifying and cloning genes that
encode the proteins of interest. The present method therefore allows the identification and cloning of genes expressed in specific cell types or tissues. Genes identified by the present method, which are expressed in a particular cell type or types and not in the subtractive cell type, proteins of interest and antisera specific for said proteins of interest are also the subject of the present invention.
In the present method, cDNA expression libraries are screened, using immunodepleted antisera which have been produced, as described herein, in such a manner that they contain antibodies which recognize (bind) antigens present in a particular cell type or types but not in at least one other cell type. This method is referred to herein as subtractive antibody screening (SAS) . Further, the present invention provides a method to remove from antisera antibodies that react with antigens found in cells other than the cell type of interest, as well as antibodies that react with antigens of previously identified proteins. The method of identifying a protein expressed in a cell type of interest and not expressed in at least one cell type other than the cell type of interest includes combining a suitable cDNA expression library and immunodepleted serum. The cDNA library can be from the cell type of interest or a different suitable cell type.
Proteins expressed by the cDNA expression library are bound by antibodies in the immunodepleted serum to form complexes. The complexes of proteins expressed by the cDNA expression library and antibodies in the immunodepleted serum are detected. The presence of complexes indicates the expression of a protein in the cell type of interest,
and the lack of expression in a cell type other than the cell type of interest. Further, the presence of complexes indicates the presence of the gene or gene fragment encoding said protein. The method of generating immunodepleted serum includes combining: 1) antiserum produced by immunizing a suitable host with proteins derived from the cell type of interest and 2) proteins obtained from at least one cell type other than the cell type of interest, under conditions appropriate for binding of antibodies in the antiserum to the antigens, producing antigen-bound antibodies, referred to as antibody-antigen complexes. The antibody-antigen complexes can be separated from the resulting immunodepleted antiserum, but it is not necessary that this be done. The immunodepleted serum, therefore, is enriched in antibodies that recognize proteins expressed in the cell or tissue of interest and that are not expressed in at least one other cell or tissue type.
The cell type of interest can be from any type of tissue, for example, normal tissue, metastatic malignant tissue, non-metastatic malignant tissue, cultured cells, or immortalized (transformed) cultured cells. The cell type of interest can be differentiated. The cell type of interest can be adipocytes, fibroblasts, C2C12 osteoblasts, C2C12 myotubes, neurocytes such as PC12 cells or HNT cells (Stratagene) . The cell type of interest can be blood cells. The cell type of interest can be progenitors of the cell types listed above.
In the embodiments of the method, the cell type of interest and the cell type other than the cell type of interest (subtractive cell) can be from the same or
different tissue or cell source. The cell type of interest can be stimulated or not, and the subtractive cell can be non-stimulated or stimulated, respectively. The cell type of interest can be normal and the subtractive cell can be transformed, malignant or metastatic. Conversely, the cell type of interest can be transformed, malignant or metastatic malignant and the subtractive cell can be normal. In addition, the cell type of interest can be transformed, malignant or metastatic and the subtractive cell non-transformed, non-malignant or non-metastatic, respectively. The cell type of interest and the subtractive cell type can be reversed (e.g., the cell type of interest can be non-transformed cells and the subtractive cell can be transformed cells) . Further, the cell type of interest can be adipocytes and the subtractive cell can be fibroblasts.
Proteins used to immunize the host can be derived from subcellular fractions of a cell type of interest, such as secreted, plasma membrane, cytoplasmic, organellar, subcellular membrane or nuclear proteins. Further, the proteins used to immunize the host can be derived from subfractions thereof, such as carbohydrate-containing plasma membrane proteins.
The proteins obtained from at least one cell type other than the cell type of interest can be modified to allow separation of antibody-antigen complexes from the antiserum by coupling the antigens to a suitable solid support, such as Sepharose, agarose, acrylamide, nitrocellulose, glass, plastic or silicone, or by chemically adding a suitable functional group, such as biotin or the steroid hapten digoxigenin, to the proteins.
A cDNA encoding a protein expressed in a cell type of interest is identified by combining a cDNA expression library and the immunodepleted serum, whereby proteins expressed by the cDNA expression library bind antibodies in the immunodepleted serum to form complexes of a protein expressed by the cDNA expression library and an antibody in the immunodepleted serum. The complexes of proteins expressed by the cDNA expression library and antibody from the cDNA expression library are detected. The cDNA library may be generated from any suitable cell type, including the cell type of interest.
A gene or fragment thereof encoding the detected protein expressed in a cell type of interest is isolated from the cDNA expression library by selecting a member of the cDNA expression library expressing the detected protein and isolating the cDNA encoding the protein.
The cell type of interest can be derived from normal tissue, metastatic malignant tissue, non-metastatic malignant tissue, cultured cells or immortalized (transformed) cultured cells. The cell type of interest can be stimulated, or unstimulated. Stimulation can include chemical addition or physiological change. Malignant or malignant-metastatic transformation and immortalization can result from chemical treatment or genetic transformation or can occur spontaneously.
As described herein, adipocyte specific proteins have been identified and cloned. The cloning of leptin has demonstrated the relevance of the adipocyte to the prevalent diseases of diabetes mellitus and obesity. This technology also can be applied to other, diverse biomedical systems that have relevance to human disease and.
therefore, can provide targets for drug discovery. The present methods can be applied to any system in which expressed proteins can be isolated before and after a relevant stimulus. The present method has several advantages. The present method promotes the cloning of genes encoding proteins expressed in specific cell types or specific subcellular fractions of said cell types. More specifically, the present method promotes the cloning of genes encoding proteins from subcellular fractions (such as plasma membrane proteins and secretory proteins) that are of great importance in drug targeting and pharmaceutical development. Further, the present method facilitates the cloning of these genes whether or not a signal sequence is present.
Another advantage of the present method is that at the time of cloning a gene of interest, antibodies directed against the encoded protein exist in the immunodepleted antiserum of the present invention that was used for the cloning. The specific antibody can be affinity-purified from the immunodepleted sera and used for initial characterization of novel proteins. Therefore, as soon as a clone is identified, the expression of its protein can be examined for desired characteristics such as response to hormone treatment. Thus, the entire process of gene discovery and protein characterization is streamlined and accelerated.
DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWING
The Figure is a schematic diagram of the method of the present invention.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
The novel method described herein is useful to systematically identify proteins that are expressed in specific tissues or cell types and are not expressed in other tissue or cell types and, optionally, to clone genes encoding these proteins.
Many proteins that are drug targets are either secreted by cells (hormones, cytokines, growth factors, enzymes, extracellular matrix (ECM) , adhesion molecules) or expressed on the cell surface (receptors, transporters, channels, ECM receptors, adhesion molecule receptors) . The present invention is particularly useful for identifying these subsets of cellular proteins. As described herein, the subtractive antibody screening method has been used to clone genes encoding cell-type specific proteins. In one embodiment, it has been used to clone genes encoding secreted proteins (e.g., a protein similar to Type VI collagen) and cell surface proteins whose expression is induced during adipogenesis. The discovery of a collagen whose expression is induced during adipogenesis has important implications for adipocyte differentiation and provides a drug target to be assessed for the treatment of obesity.
The present method is useful to identify expressed proteins from a particular (target) tissue or cell type. The method is useful to identify proteins that are expressed in a target tissue or cell type and not expressed in other (subtractive) tissue or cell type(s) . The present method is useful to identify and, optionally, clone genes encoding proteins from a particular tissue or cell type of interest before and after a relevant stimulus. Furthermore, the present methods can be applied to expressed proteins from a particular tissue or cell type of
interest relative to other tissue(s) or other cell type(s) without treatment or stimulation.
The cells of interest (either stimulated or not stimulated) are referred to herein as the "target tissue(s) or target cell(s)". The term "subtractive tissue(s)" or "subtractive cell(s)" refers to cell types or tissues other than the cell type of interest. In the case in which target cells are stimulated cells of a particular type, subtractive cells can be nonstimulated cells of the same type, nonstimulated cells of another type or types or stimulated cells of another cell type. Furthermore, in the case in which target cells are nonstimulated cells of a particular type, subtractive cells can be stimulated cells of the same type, stimulated cells of another type or types or nonstimulated cells of another cell type. Similarly, in those embodiments in which the cell type of interest is a transformed cell, a malignant cell or a metastatic cell, the cell type other than the cell type of interest can be, for example, respectively, the corresponding nontransformed cell, nonmalignant cell or nonmetastatic cell.
Alternatively, the cell type other than the cell type of interest can be cells of another type or types (not the same cell type as the cell type of interest) .
The method, referred to as subtractive antibody' screening (SAS) , is useful to identify and clone genes and identify and, optionally, isolate, the encoded proteins from any type of target cell, including procaryotic (e.g. bacterial) and eucaryotic (e.g., fungal, insect, plant, vertebrate, mammalian, human) cells for which expressed proteins can be isolated. Human tissue and cell types, including, but not limited to, endothelial cells, epithelial cells, hepatocytes, fibroblasts, nervous tissue, blood cells, muscle cells, cells of the immune system (e.g. macrophage, mast cells, T cells, B cells) , transformed
cells (i.e. immortalized cells) and malignant transformed cells (i.e. immortalized and non-contact inhibited cells) and metastatic malignant cells can be screened- y the method described herein to identify proteins and the genes encoding the proteins.
The target cells can be derived directly from an organism, derived from an organism and then passaged in culture (primary culture) or derived from an immortalized cell line. The tissue of interest, which includes the target cells, may comprise one cell type, such as in nervous tissue, or multiple cell types, such as in connective tissue. The tissue of interest can be employed immediately after isolation from an organism, after a period of incubation or after being maintained by perfusion or other means of preservation.
In one embodiment, the target cells and subtractive cell counterparts may be, respectively, stimulated and nonstimulated versions of the same cell type or tissue of interest. In another embodiment, the target cell and subtractive cell counterparts may be two different cell types or tissues, either stimulated or not.
The stimulus to which target cells are subjected can be, for example, a physiological change (e.g., altered temperature, osmolarity or nutritional supplement) , shear stress, ischemia, hormone treatment, cellular transformation, incubation for a period of time (in the case of tissue samples or primary cell culture) or chemical treatment. Further, the stimulus can be a differentiation protocol involving one or more of the previously described stimuli.
Subtractive antibody screening is carried out by immunoscreening a cDNA expression library from a suitable cell type with polyclonal antisera. As used herein, the term "cDNA expression library from a suitable cell type"
refers to a collection of genes expressed in the cell type. The cDNA expression library is a library that represents the transcribed genes of a cell, at the same relative abundance as that found in the cell. The cDNA expression library is prepared from a suitable cell type using methods known to those of skill in the art (see, e.g. pages 7.1- 7.35, 8.1-81 and 12.1-12.44, Molecular Cloning, a Laboratory Manual Second Edition, J. Sambrook et al . , (Eds.); pages 4.0.1-5.11.2, Current Protocols in Molecular Biology, F. Ausubel et al . , (Eds.)) and introduced into the appropriate host cell. In one embodiment, the cDNA expression library is prepared from the target cells in which protein expression is to be assessed. The expression library is prepared from the mRNA of the cells. The mRNA is inserted as a cDNA copy into any vector that allows expression of the cDNA insert in a host cell (expression host) . Many suitable expression vectors are known to those of skill in the art, as are suitable expression hosts (such as bacteria, yeast, insect cells and vertebrate cells, including mammalian cell culture) for the particular expression vector. In another embodiment, the cDNA library can be a subtractive cDNA library. Methods for generating subtractive cDNA libraries are well known in the art.
Polyclonal antiserum is prepared against proteins of the target cells according to known methods (see, e.g., pages 53-137, Antibodies, a Laboratory Manual, E. Harlow and D. Lane, (Eds.) and is depleted of antibodies that react with proteins expressed in subtractive cells.
The proteins used to deplete the polyclonal antiserum of antibodies that react with proteins expressed in subtractive cells are referred to as i munodepletion antigens and can be derived from progenitors or derivatives of the target cells (e.g., before treatment or stimulation or after) or can be derived from a separate cell sample
which has not been treated or stimulated. The immunodepletion antigens isolated from the subtractive cells can be modified to facilitate isolation of the antigens and bound antibodies away from solution. The antigens can be immobilized onto a solid support such as a resin (e.g. Sepharose, agarose or acrylamide) or other solid support, such as nitrocellulose, glass, plastic or silicone. Alternatively, the immunodepletion antigens can be chemically modified to facilitate their removal from solution. For example, immunodepletion antigens can be chemically modified with biotin to facilitate isolation using immobilized avidin or streptavidin. Immunodepletion antigens can also be chemically modified with the steroid hapten digoxigenin to facilitate isolation using immobilized anti-digoxigenin antibodies.
Immunodepleted serum, which is serum from which antibodies that bind proteins expressed in at least one cell type other than the target cell type have been removed, is prepared by 1) combining the polyclonal serum, described above, and the immunodepletion antigens; and 2) maintaining the resulting combination under conditions appropriate for antigen-antibody binding to occur, resulting in antigen-bound antibodies and thus, producing immunodepleted serum. In another embodiment, the aritigen- bound antibodies are removed from the polyclonal serum. Immunoscreening is carried out under conditions appropriate for binding of antibodies with antigens (see, e.g. pages 12.1-12.44, Molecular Cloning, a Laboratory Manual Second Edition, J. Sambrook et al . , (Eds.); and pages 6.0.1-6.12.12, Current Protocols in Molecular
Biology, F. Ausubel et al . , (Eds.)). Expression hosts expressing the cDNA library are induced with conditions that permit expression of the cDNA. The expression hosts are combined with immunodepleted serum under conditions
appropriate for specific binding of antibodies to protein expressed by the cDNA to occur, wherein antibodies that bind proteins of interest but do not bind proteins from a cell type other than the cell type of interest are specific antibodies, with the result that complexes of a protein expressed by the cDNA expression library and an antibody in the immunodepleted serum are generated. Complexes of antibodies in the immunodepleted serum bound to proteins in the cDNA expression library are detected. Presence of complexes is indicative of the presence of a protein expressed in the cell type of interest. Expression host cell(s) harboring the cDNA expressing an antibody-bound protein is/are identified. In one embodiment, the expression hosts are immobilized on a solid support and then lysed or permeabilized, if necessary, to allow antibody binding. In another embodiment, the expression host cell(s) are permeabilized, if necessary, and combined or contacted with immunodepleted serum, under conditions which permit antibody antigen binding. The antibody-bound expression hosts can be isolated by fluorescence-activated cell sorting or by binding to Protein A-coated beads followed by isolation of the beads together with antibody bound expression hosts.
The nucleic acid (DNA, RNA) encoding the protein can be isolated using methods well known in the art from the expression host(s) identified as described above. The isolated nucleic acid (DNA, RNA) can also be amplified and characterized using methods well known in the art. Further, the isolated nucleic acid can be used as a probe to isolate full length cDNA encoding the protein of interest (if it is not already a full length clone) , or can be used as a probe to isolate related sequences, such as those encoding homologues or family members of the protein of interest.
In one embodiment, proteins of a particular subcellular fraction of target cells are used to generate polyclonal antisera as described above. Proteins from the corresponding subcellular fraction of the subtractive cells are immobilized as described above and used to immunodeplete the polyclonal antiserum generated against antigens from the target cells. Proteins from lysates of subtractive cells can also be employed as immunodepletion antigens. In one embodiment, post nuclear supernatants (whole cell lysates with nuclei removed) are used to immunodeplete the polyclonal antiserum. The polyclonal antiserum can be further immunodepleted against known antigenic proteins such as hsp60 and hsp70.
The resulting immunodepleted antiserum is used to screen an expression library (e.g., a lambda phage expression library) prepared from a suitable cell type or from target cells of interest or target cells treated in the same manner as target cells used to raise the polyclonal serum. Proteins bound by the antibodies of the immunodepleted antiserum are proteins expressed in the target cells but not in the subtractive cells used to generate the immunodepletion antigens. As a result, proteins expressed in the target cells or subcellular fraction of target cells and not expressed in subtractive cells are identified. Antibody-bound antigens and DNA encoding the bound antigens are identified and isolated using known methods. The isolated DNA can be sequenced and analyzed.
The polyclonal antiserum can be further immunodepleted against proteins identified using this method, to prevent redundant identification in subsequent immunoscreening procedures.
To simplify the description of the following embodiments, the condition where the target cells are
stimulated and the subtractive cells are the same type of cells as the target cells, but are not stimulated is described. It is understood that in a different embodiment, the target cells can be unstimulated and the subtractive cells can be the same type of cells as the target cells, but are stimulated. Further, in another embodiment the target cells can be one type of cell and the subtractive a different type of cell, both types stimulated or not. In one embodiment, genes encoding proteins from a subcellular fraction of the target cells are cloned. For example, cytoplasmic proteins can be identified and cloned by the present method. In this embodiment, subtractive cells are lysed and fractionated according to known methods to isolate cytosol away from membranes, organelles and nuclei. Proteins released from the cells (proteins in the cytosol) are immobilized onto a solid support as described above. Proteins from lysates of subtractive cells can also be employed as immunodepletion antigens (as described above) . Known highly antigenic proteins such as hsp60 and hsp70 can also be employed as immunodepletion agents to reduce the likelihood that such non-target proteins will not be detected in the screening process.
Target cells are lysed in the same manner as described above and the isolated cytoplasmic proteins are used to generate polyclonal antiserum according to known methods. The resulting antiserum is then immunodepleted of antibodies that bind antigens isolated from the subtractive cells by reacting the polyclonal serum with the proteins immobilized as described above. The resulting antiserum is then used to immunoscreen a suitable cDNA expression library. Antibodies in the immunodepleted serum recognize, bind and form complexes with proteins expressed by the cDNA expression library. The antigen-antibody complexes are
detected, and the protein and polynucleotide encoding the protein are identified and optionally isolated.
Nuclear proteins can also be identified and cloned by the present method. For example, nuclei can be isolated from subtractive cells and nuclear extracts prepared according to known methods. Proteins in the resulting nuclear extracts are immobilized onto a surface as described above. Proteins from whole cell lysates of subtractive cells can also be employed as immunodepletion antigens (as described above) . Known antigenic proteins such as hsp60 and hsp70 can also be employed as immunodepletion agents.
Nuclei from target cells are isolated and nuclear extract prepared according to standard methods known in the art. Polyclonal antiserum is produced against the preparation of nuclear extract from the target cells. The resulting antiserum is immunodepleted of antibodies that bind antigens isolated from the subtractive cells. The resulting immunodepleted antiserum is then used to immunoscreen a suitable cDNA expression library.
Antibodies in the immunodepleted serum recognize, bind and form complexes with proteins expressed by the cDNA expression library. The antigen-antibody complexes are detected, and the protein and polynucleotide encoding the protein are identified and optionally isolated.
In another embodiment, subtractive antibody screening can be used to identify and clone secreted proteins and genes encoding these proteins from the target cells. Polyclonal antisera are raised against the total complement of secretory proteins from the target cells. This antiserum is then immunodepleted of binding activity against secreted proteins from the subtractive cells, by reacting the polyclonal serum with the immobilized secretory proteins of the subtractive cells. Proteins from
whole lysates of subtractive cells can also be employed as immunodepletion antigens (as described above) . Known antigenic proteins such as hsp60 and hsp70 can- also be employed as immunodepletion agents. The resulting immunodepleted antiserum is used to immunoscreen a suitable cDNA expression library. Antibodies in the immunodepleted serum recognize, bind and form complexes with proteins expressed by the cDNA expression library. The antigen- antibody complexes are detected, and the protein and polynucleotide encoding the protein are identified and optionally isolated.
As described in the Examples, the present method has been carried out to identify proteins expressed in adipocytes (target cells) and not expressed in fibroblasts (subtractive cells) . Specifically, 3T3-L1 fibroblasts were used. As described in Example 1, 3T3-L1 fibroblasts were induced to differentiate into adipocytes over eight days. Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis was used to demonstrate that at least thirty proteins are secreted by adipocytes that are not secreted by fibroblasts. Polyclonal antisera were raised against the total complement of secretory proteins from adipocytes. To do this, serum-free conditioned media from 3T3-L1 adipocytes were collected and concentrated. This material was used to immunize rabbits, and the resulting antisera were collected. The total complement of secretory proteins from fibroblasts and protein from lysed fibroblasts were collected, concentrated and used to generate the immunodepletion agent as described above and in Example 2. The polyclonal antisera were systematically immunodepleted of antibodies that react with the immobilized fibroblast proteins described above. Known antigenic proteins such as hsp60 and hsp70 were also employed as immunodepletion agents. Antisera subjected to several such depletion steps were highly enriched in
antibodies that recognize adipocyte-specific secretory proteins.
As described in Example 4, the immunodepleted antiserum recognizes several proteins whose expression and/or secretion is modulated by chronic insulin treatment. This antiserum also recognizes at least eight circulating proteins from mouse serum. The immunodepleted antiserum was used to immunoscreen a lambda phage expression library prepared from 3T3-L1 adipocytes. This resulted in the identification of a number of genes encoding previously identified proteins, as well as at least five novel genes. Blast search at the National Center for Biotechnology and Information and Northern blot analysis was used to confirm the tissue specificity of the isolated clones. More than half of the positive clones identified with the subtractive antibody screening method described herein represented known secretory proteins. Some proteins identified are known to be secreted by adipocytes (e.g. , fibronectin, complement factor C3) and some not previously described as being adipocyte secreted proteins (e.g., osteonectin and alpha-1 acid glycoprotein) . As described in Example 7, Northern blot analysis of mouse tissues showed that mouse adipose tissue has higher levels of osteonectin messenger RNA per microgram of RNA than any other tissue examined. Thus, the unexpected cloning of osteonectin with the subtractive antibody screening method reflects a true adipose tissue phenomenon, and not merely a cell culture artifact.
As described in Example 7 , one of the novel genes cloned demonstrates homology to the alpha 3 subunit of human Type VI collagen (α3(VI) collagen). The expression of the gene is elevated in adipocytes, as determined by Northern blot. Discovery of a collagen that is induced during adipocyte differentiation is significant because of
the role that the ECM plays in mesenchymal cell differentiation. Adipocyte precursors share a common lineage with chondrocyte, osteoblast, and smooth muscle cell precursors. In the case of osteoblasts, cytokines such as TGFβ and bone morphogenic proteins are sequestered and concentrated by the ECM, and these proteins influence osteoblast differentiation. Similarly, the ECM that surrounds adipocytes may trap soluble factors that influence adipocyte differentiation and/or function. The ECM also forms the physical bed in which the adipocytes lie. Thus, the collagen identified and cloned by the present method is a promising target for modulating adipocyte differentiation and function.
In another embodiment, cell surface proteins can be identified and cloned by the present method. For example, intact subtractive cells are surface labeled (e.g., by addition of a member of a binding pair, such as biotin) before stimulation and the resulting labeled (e.g., biotinylated) proteins are immobilized on a solid support (e.g., a resin) that has attached thereto the second member of the binding pair (e.g., streptavidin) . Intact target cells are stimulated and then surface labeled (e.g., by addition of a member of a binding pair, such as biotin) and the resulting labeled (e.g., biotinylated) proteins are purified over a solid support (e.g. , a resin) which has attached thereto the second member of the binding pair (e.g., streptavidin). Proteins bound to the solid support as a result of binding of biotin with streptavidin are surface proteins of the stimulated target cells. In one embodiment, the solid support can be washed to remove proteins that associate indirectly with the plasma membrane (e.g. via a biotinylated protein) . Such conditions include high salt concentration, high pH or the presence of an ionizing detergent, such as SDS. The labeled proteins are
released and polyclonal antiserum is generated against the eluted material. This antiserum is then immunodepleted of activity against proteins from the subtractive -cells by reacting the polyclonal serum with the biotinylated, immobilized proteins described above. Further, the polyclonal antiserum can be immunodepleted against surface proteins of intact live cells. Known antigenic proteins such as hsp60 and hsp70 can also be employed as immunodepletion agents. The resulting antiserum is then used to immunoscreen a suitable cDNA expression library. Antibodies in the immunodepleted serum recognize, bind and form complexes with proteins expressed by the cDNA expression library. The antigen-antibody complexes are detected, and the protein and nucleotide encoding the protein identified and optionally isolated.
In a particular embodiment of a method of identifying and cloning the genes for surface proteins, intact adipocytes (target cells) were biotinylated with sulfo-NHS- SS-biotin (Pierce) . The resulting biotinylated proteins were purified over a solid support (e.g., a resin) that had streptavidin attached thereto. Proteins bound to the solid support as a result of binding of biotin with streptavidin were adipocyte proteins. The surface-labeled proteins were released from the solid support using reducing conditions to break the disulfide bond in the NHS-SS-biotin (according to the manufacturer's instructions) and used to immunize rabbits. The resulting antiserum contained a high titer of antibodies against adipocyte surface proteins, as determined by immunofluorescence. This antiserum was then depleted of activity against fibroblast (subtractive cells) surface proteins, post nuclear supernatant proteins, and against hsp60 and hsp70 as described above for secreted proteins. Further, the polyclonal antiserum was immunodepleted against surface proteins of intact live
fibroblasts. Intact, live fibroblasts were washed with ice cold phosphate buffered saline to remove serum proteins and incubated with the immunodepleted polyclonal antisera at 4° C for 1-12 hours. The antiserum was harvested away from the cells and used for cloning. Several novel cDNA clones were identified, one of which has been fully characterized and shown to be adipocyte specific.
In another embodiment, intact adipocytes can be employed to affinity purify adipocyte-specific antibodies. Immunodepleted serum is incubated at 4°C with washed, allowing binding antibodies with adipocyte surface proteins. Adipocytes are washed to remove unbound antibodies. Bound antibodies are eluted using methods well known in the art. In one embodiment, antibodies are eluted from the cells with 100 mM glycine at pH 2.5. After elution, the pH is neutralized with 1 M Tris, pH 8.0. The resulting affinity purified antibodies can be used to immunoscreen a suitable cDNA library.
In other embodiments, genes encoding proteins from subcellular fractions such as organellar fractions or subcellular membrane fractions other than the plasma membrane can be cloned. These subcellular fractions can be isolated using methods well known in the art. Further, genes encoding proteins from subfractions thereof, such as carbohydrate-containing plasma membrane proteins can be cloned.
In one embodiment, the present method is useful to identify proteins and clone the genes encoding the proteins expressed at different stages of development. For example, genes encoding proteins expressed at specific stages or in specific regions of a developing embryo are systematically identified and cloned from appropriately stimulated embryonic stem cells or from fertilized eggs. The stimulated stem cells or the fertilized eggs can be
maintained in vitro or in vivo. The fertilized eggs can be from any organism suitable as a source for eggs, such as spistula clam, drosophila, sea urchin, frog, chicken or mouse. In another embodiment, genes encoding proteins expressed at specific stages of differentiation in a wide variety of cell types can be identified and cloned. For example, genes encoding proteins expressed at specific stages of blood cell differentiation, neuronal cell differentiation, osteoblast differentiation, myotube differentiation or epithelial cell differentiation can be cloned from appropriately treated progenitor cells, using standard methods known in the art. Blood cells such as mast cells, B cells, T cells, macrophages, erythroblasts and megakaryocytes can be generated from appropriately stimulated hematopoietic stem cells. Neuronal cells can be generated from appropriately stimulated neuronal cells such as PC12 cells or HNT cells (Stratagene) . Osteoblasts can be generated from appropriately stimulated C2C12 cells. Myotubes can be generated from appropriately stimulated C2C12 cells.
The present method is also useful to systematically identify and clone genes encoding proteins that are expressed in a wide variety of abnormally proliferating cells, including malignant, malignant metastatic and immortalized cells. These abnormally proliferating cells can be obtained from sources in which they occur in nature (e.g., tumors) or be induced by chemical treatment or oncogene transfection of normal cells to generate transformed or malignant cells or of transformed cells to generate malignant cells.
In one embodiment, genes specific for stressed (but not non-stressed) tissue or primary cell culture are cloned. In a more specific embodiment, tissue or primary
cell culture is exposed to shear stress or stressed with heat, cold, osmolarity, nutrition or ischemia. In another embodiment, genes specific for tissue or cell culture treated with a specific hormone, cytokine or other biological agent (but not non-treated tissue or cell culture) are cloned. In another embodiment, genes expressed in a particular type of tissue (but not in at least one other type of tissue) are cloned. In yet another embodiment, genes specific for freshly isolated tissue (but not in corresponding primary culture) are cloned.
The following Examples are offered for the purpose of illustrating the present invention and are not to be construed to limit the scope of this invention. The teachings of all cited references are hereby incorporated herein by reference.
EXAMPLES
Example 1 Generation of polyclonal antiserum against proteins secreted by adipocytes. Sixty 15 centimeter diameter culture dishes of 3T3-L1 cells (American Type Culture Collection, Rockville, MD) were differentiated according to a standard protocol (Frost, S.C., and Lane, M.D. (1985) J. Biol Chem 260:2646- 2652) . After 8 days, the cells were washed five times with Dulbecco's Modified Eagle's Medium (DMEM) to remove all traces of fetal calf serum from the culture medium. Each dish of cells was subsequently incubated in 10 ml serum- free DMEM; 30 of the plates were also supplemented with 160 nM insulin. After 8 hours, the culture media were harvested. Detached cells were removed by centrifugation (10,000 g for 20 min) .
The proteins secreted by the adipocytes were concentrated with Centricon units (Amicon Inc.) using a
molecular mass cutoff of 2000 Da. The proteins from this subcellular fraction were mixed with Ribi Adjuvant (RIBI Immunochem Research Inc) according to the manufacturer's instructions and injected subcutaneously into rabbits at 4 week intervals. Each injection contained about 250 μg of total protein as judged by Coomassie-Blue staining of a small fraction of the sample. Antiserum was collected from the immunized rabbits.
Example 2 Generation of immunodepletion antigens To generate immobilized antigens from the material secreted from the cells of interest for immunodepletion of the polyclonal sera of Example 1, serum free media from thirty 15 centimeter diameter culture dishes of preconfluent fibroblasts were harvested and concentrated as described above, dialyzed overnight against 100 mM Na- Carbonate Buffer, pH 8.5, containing 500 mM NaCl, and subsequently coupled to CNBr-Sepharose (Pharmacia) according to the manufacturer's instructions, thus immobilizing immunodepletion antigens of secreted proteins. In parallel, preconfluent fibroblasts were lysed in TNET-OG (1% Triton X-100, 60 mM octyl-glucoside, 150 mM NaCl, 20 mM Tris, pH 8.0, 2 mM EDTA, 1 mM PMSF) . The nuclei were removed by centrifugation and the resulting supernatant was dialyzed against carbonate buffer and coupled to CNBr-Sepharose as described above, thus generating immobilized immunodepletion antigens of total fibroblast proteins.
It is clear that many factors can be altered such as the medium used to harvest the antigens, the detergent used to harvest the antigens, the dialysis buffer and the coupling column in order to attain the desired outcome of immobilized antigens representative of the proteins of a
tissue or cell line to be used to immunodeplete the polyclonal sera of Example 1.
Example 3 Generation of Immunodepleted antisera for subtractive antibody screening Antiserum collected from the immunized rabbits in Example 1 was incubated overnight at 4°C with the immobilized immunodepletion antigens of secreted proteins from Example 2, to deplete the antiserum of antibodies recognizing antigens present in the pre-adipocyte fibroblasts used as the source of immunodepletion antigens. This process can be repeated several times with one or more immunodepletion resins to facilitate depletion of the antisera. Additionally, in order to deplete the serum of antibodies against intracellular proteins known to have very high antigenicity such as heat shock proteins of the hsp60 and hsp70 families, T7 gene 10/hsp60 and T7 gene 10/hsp70 fusion proteins were transferred to nitrocellulose and these membranes were used for immunodepletion.
Example 4 Immunoprecipitation of 35S-labeled proteins secreted by day 8 3T3-L1 adipocytes
Two 10 centimeter diameter plates of 3T3-L1 adipocytes were incubated overnight in serum-free medium either in the absence or the presence of 1 μM insulin. The plates were then labeled for 30 minutes with 1 mCi of 35S-Express protein labeling reagent, again in the presence or absence of insulin. The medium was removed and plates washed 3 times with DMEM. The plates were then incubated for an additional 3 hours with or without insulin. The media were then harvested, insoluble debris removed by centrifugation and the supernatants either analyzed directly (5% of total material) or immunoprecipitated with the immunodepleted antiserum. A distinct subset of the total mixture of
secreted proteins was immunoprecipitated by the immunodepleted serum. The level of expression of some of these proteins was affected (either repressed or induced) by chronic insulin treatment.
Example 5 Construction of a directional 3T3-L1 adipocyte phage cDNA library Poly(A) + RNA (5 μg) from 3T3-L1 adipocytes at day eight of differentiation was used as the template to construct a λEXlox™ library according to the manufacturer's instructions (Novagen, Inc., Madison, WI) . Oligo(dT) was used to prime the first-strand cDNA synthesis. Prior to ligation to the phage arms, the cDNA was size-fractionated (>1.5 kb) using a 5%-20% potassium acetate gradient (Aruffo, A., and Seed, B. (1987) Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . U. S.A. 84:8573-8577). The resulting library represented approximately 1 X 106 independent clones. The library was amplified once and used for screening.
Example 6 Expression cloning. Screening of 5xl05 phage particles was done according to standard protocols with minor modifications as described in the λEXlox™ manual (Novagen, Inc.). Nitrocellulose filters were blocked in TBS-T (50 mM Tris, pH 8.0, 150 mM NaCl, 0.05% Tween 20) containing 1% Bovine Serum Albumin (TBS-T/BSA) . Antibody incubations were performed in TBS- T/BSA overnight at 4δC. Filters were washed 4 times in TBS-T, incubated with 20U of digoxigenin-coupled anti- rabbit antibodies (Boehringer Inc.) in TBS-T/BSA for 1 hour at room temperature. Then the filters were washed another 4 times with TBS-T, followed by one wash with 100 mM Tris, pH 9.0, 100 mM MgCl2. Positive clones were identified by a colorimetric assay using 1-Step BCIP/NBT (Pierce) .
Example 7 mRNA Isolation and Analysis of Identified
Clones mRNA was isolated from tissues and from 3T3-L1 cells at various stages of differentiation. The mRNA was separated by agarose gel electrophoresis and transferred to nylon membranes and DNA probes were [32P] labeled according to (Baldini, G. , Holh, T. , Lin, H.Y., and Lodish, H.F. (1992) Proc . Natl . Acad . Sci . USA 89:5049-5052). Hybridization of the labeled probe to the nylon membranes was performed overnight at 42°C in 50% formamide, 5x SSC, 25 mM Na-phosphate, pH 7.0, lOx Denhardt's solution, 5 mM EDTA, 1% SDS, and 0.1 mg/ml polyA; the [32P] DNA probes were used at 2xl06 cpm/ml. The membranes were subsequently washed in 2x SSC/0.1% SDS and O.lx SSC/0.1% SDS at 50°C. The same membranes were thereafter stripped and reprobed with a radiolabeled cDNA encoding one of the constitutively expressed proteins - cytosolic hsp70 (Hunt, C. , and Calderwood, S. (1990) Gene 87:199-204; Scherer, P.E., Lisanti, M.P., Baldini, G. , Sargiacomo, M. , Corley-Mastick, C, and Lodish, H.F. (1994) J Cell Biol 127:1233-1243) and a partial clone of mouse Sec23 (Wadhwa, R. , Kaul, S.C., Komatsu, Y., Ikawa, Y., Sarai, A., and Sugimoto, Y. (1993) FEBS Lett 315:193-196).
Of the clones characterized, five were novel, and five encoded four known secretory proteins. Two of these were known to be secreted by adipocytes - fibronectin (Spiegelman, B.M. , and Ginty, CA. (1983) Cell 35:657-666) and complement factor C3 (Choy, L.N. , Rosen, B.S., and Spiegelman, B.M. (1992) J Biol Chem 267 : 12736-12741) - while others have not been described as adipocyte secretory proteins - osteonectin (Lane, T.F., and Sage, E.H. (1994) FASEB J 8:163-173) and alpha-1 acid glycoprotein (Ricca, G.A. , Hamilton, R.W. , McLean, J.W. , Conn, A., Kalinyak, J.E., and Taylor, J.M. (1981) J Biol Chem 256:10362-10368).
One of the clones, B52, was found to be the mouse homologue of the α3 subunit of human type VI collagen.
The tissue distribution of two of the clones, B52, and osteonectin was tested by Northern blot analysis. B52 was found to be expressed in fat tissue and 3T3-L1 adipocytes and not in mouse kidney, liver, brain, testis, diaphragm, heart, lung or spleen. Osteonectin was most highly expressed in mouse fat tissue, highly expressed in lung, expressed at a low level in brain, diaphragm, heart and 3T3-L1 adipocytes, but not expressed in kidney, liver, testis and spleen. Expression of the B52 during differentiation of precursor fibroblasts to adipocytes was measured by Northern blot analysis. B52 mRNA was found to be highly induced during differentiation, and can be detected within two days after the cells reach confluence.
Example 8 Isolation of a full-length 3(VI) collagen cDNA The full-length clone of B52 (9kb) was isolated by a combination of screening the λEXlox™ cDNA library as well as a 5 ' - stretch mouse fat library (Clonetech) and nested PCR. The λEXlox™ cDNA library and 5' - stretch mouse fat library were screened with digoxygenin-labeled (Boehringer) probes comprising the 300 most 5' nucleotides of the clone obtained by SAS, resulting in overlapping clones that lacked the 5' most 4000 nucleotides of the putative full- length gene. The 5' end of the full-length gene was obtained by nested PCR using the day 8 adipocyte cDNA library together with vector-based primers for the 5' end and a set of nested primers at the 3' end. PCR products were subcloned into pZero (Invitrogen) and subjected to automated sequencing.
Example 9 Radiolabeling and Immunoprecipitations.
3T3-L1 adipocytes were incubated for 30 min in DMEM lacking cysteine and methionine (ICN, Costa Mesa) and then labeled for 10 min in the same medium containing 0.5 mCi/ml of 35S Express Protein Labeling Reagent (1000 Ci/mmol) [NEN (Boston, MA) ] . The cells were then washed twice with DMEM supplemented with unlabeled cysteine and methionine and then fresh growth medium was added. After three hours of incubation at 372C, the medium was collected and the cells lysed in lysis buffer (1% Triton X-100, 60 mM octyl- glucoside, 150 mM NaCl, 20 mM Tris pH 8.0, 2 mM EDTA, 1 mM PMSF) . Insoluble material from both the medium and cell lysate was removed by centrifugation (15,000 g for 10 min). The supernatants were precleared with 50 μl Protein A - Sepharose for 30 min at 42C and then immunoprecipitated with antibody for 3 hrs at 4fiC. Immunoprecipitates were washed 4 times in lysis buffer lacking octyl-glucoside.
Separation of proteins by SDS-PAGE, fluorography, immunoblotting, protein determinations and densitometric scanning of the gels were performed as described previously (Scherer et al . 1994). Automated DNA Sequencing was performed on a Applied Biosystems apparatus (Model PE/ABI 373A) by the Whitehead Institute Sequencing Facility.
EQUIVALENTS Those skilled in the art will recognize, or be able to ascertain, using no more than routine experimentation, many equivalents to the specific embodiments of the invention described herein. Such equivalents are intended to be encompassed by the following claims: