lily - mainly crime, classical literature, distopias and poetry, or anything about greek mythology or phsychology but she reads basically anything you put before her
mary - feminist novels, fashion magazines, political and history books & romance, especially classical
marlene - the back of shampoo bottles and cereal boxes, random billboards, news outlets, physics chemistry and biology books, comics, fantasy books advertized for kids like percy jackson, michael vey or the hunger games
dorcas - dark gothic novels and poetry, feminist novels, anything from stephen king, frankeinstein type shit
pandora - herbariums, books about magical creatures & plants, fantasy, conspiracy theories, every prophecy book in existence, fanfiction for sure, comics
emmeline - literally anything, her favourites are comics of any kind, fantasy or farytales, gothic novels and classical literature
hestia - classical romance, poetry, newspaper, fanfiction (she'd write too)
amelia - fashion magazines, queer romance, fanfiction, supernatural stuff like twilight, mangas
emma - i headcanon them to be dyslexic, so probably not much, they like comics though
wendy - sci-fi, tolkien, game of thrones type shit, basically anything from the 70s or anything with female protagonists, comics
charity - SMUT like colleen hoover type shit, booktok books in general
rita - i dont have better words for her taste than "posh" books like jane austen's, oscar wilde, agatha cristie, etc, she'd probably read and love fifty shades of gray too
aurora - basically anything about stars, astrology or greek mythology, poetry, horror
zelmira (mrs. zabini) - she'd LOVE the 7 husbands of evelyn hugo and and basically every other taylor jenkins reid book
sybill - classical literature, astrology, future telling, buddhist and plant stuff, distopias and eutopias
alice - i can't explain it in other words, they read anything with an autumn vibe and they only read library or used books, don't ask me why
narcissa - poetry, classical books especially romance, horror novels, shakespeare plays, plays in general, queer stories
andromeda - very big on classical literature poetry and plays, will read literally anything from that period
bellatrix -dark novels, serial killer biographies, basically anything that involves death and suffering, psychology (psych major bellatrix??), newspaper