CN106230773A - Risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP) - Google Patents
Risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP) Download PDFInfo
- Publication number
- CN106230773A CN106230773A CN201610541641.7A CN201610541641A CN106230773A CN 106230773 A CN106230773 A CN 106230773A CN 201610541641 A CN201610541641 A CN 201610541641A CN 106230773 A CN106230773 A CN 106230773A
- Authority
- CN
- China
- Prior art keywords
- index
- risk
- fuzzy
- sub
- matter sources
- Prior art date
- Legal status (The legal status is an assumption and is not a legal conclusion. Google has not performed a legal analysis and makes no representation as to the accuracy of the status listed.)
- Withdrawn
Links
Classifications
-
- G—PHYSICS
- G06—COMPUTING OR CALCULATING; COUNTING
- G06N—COMPUTING ARRANGEMENTS BASED ON SPECIFIC COMPUTATIONAL MODELS
- G06N7/00—Computing arrangements based on specific mathematical models
- G06N7/02—Computing arrangements based on specific mathematical models using fuzzy logic
-
- H—ELECTRICITY
- H04—ELECTRIC COMMUNICATION TECHNIQUE
- H04L—TRANSMISSION OF DIGITAL INFORMATION, e.g. TELEGRAPHIC COMMUNICATION
- H04L63/00—Network architectures or network communication protocols for network security
- H04L63/20—Network architectures or network communication protocols for network security for managing network security; network security policies in general
Landscapes
- Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
- Software Systems (AREA)
- Computer Security & Cryptography (AREA)
- Theoretical Computer Science (AREA)
- General Engineering & Computer Science (AREA)
- Computing Systems (AREA)
- General Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
- Physics & Mathematics (AREA)
- Evolutionary Computation (AREA)
- Mathematical Optimization (AREA)
- Algebra (AREA)
- Artificial Intelligence (AREA)
- Computational Mathematics (AREA)
- Data Mining & Analysis (AREA)
- Health & Medical Sciences (AREA)
- General Health & Medical Sciences (AREA)
- Mathematical Analysis (AREA)
- Molecular Biology (AREA)
- Pure & Applied Mathematics (AREA)
- Fuzzy Systems (AREA)
- Biomedical Technology (AREA)
- Mathematical Physics (AREA)
- Automation & Control Theory (AREA)
- Life Sciences & Earth Sciences (AREA)
- Computer Hardware Design (AREA)
- Computer Networks & Wireless Communication (AREA)
- Signal Processing (AREA)
- Management, Administration, Business Operations System, And Electronic Commerce (AREA)
Abstract
The invention discloses risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP), building module, fuzzy overall evaluation result computing module and risk evaluation module including evaluation criteria system generation module, opinion rating system generation module, quantification of targets module, index weights computing module, subordinated-degree matrix, wherein risk evaluation module includes risk profiles assessment submodule, risk analysis submodule and risk control submodule.Present invention risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP), the application in risk assessment by fuzzy matrix and analytic hierarchy process (AHP), the various uncertain factors, the index that occur during risk assessment can be analyzed.
Description
Technical field
The present invention relates to technical field of network security, be specifically related to risk assessment system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP)
System.
Background technology
In correlation technique, in the risk assessment processes of network security, there are the character of a lot of influence factor and the activity cannot
Carrying out quantitative description by numeral, result cannot judge by single criterion, therefore at many employing fuzzy mathematics methods
Reason.American scholar L.A.Zadeth proposes the concept of fuzzy set first in nineteen sixty-five, and fuzzy behavior and activity are set up model.
Fuzzy mathematics is transferred to continuous logic on the basis of two-valued function, and absolute "Yes" and " non-" are become the most flexibly
Thing, goes to process blooming with strict mathematical method.
Additionally, analytic hierarchy process (AHP) (Analytic Hierarchy Process is called for short AHP) is also conventional means, it is
A kind of simplicity that the eighties in 20th century is proposed by U.S. operational research professor T.L.Satty, flexible and practical multiple criteria decision making (MCDM)
Method, PROBLEM DECOMPOSITION is different compositing factors according to the character of problem and target to be reached by it, and according to factor between
Interrelated impact and membership are pressed different levels and are assembled combination, form a multi-level analytical structure model,
Then pressing layer analysis, final acquisition lowermost layer factor is for the importance weight of top (general objective).
In correlation technique, in the risk assessment of network security, conventional Forecasting Methodology mainly has:
Expert prediction method, refers to that being formed expert group by multiple experts carries out a kind of method of risk profile, can be divided into two kinds
Mode: one is that tissue relevant expert investigates, and then the conclusion drawing prediction is discussed by the way of forum;Two are
Delphi approach, when transporting in this way, by coordinator with note formats, sends problem table to relevant expert, it is desirable to expert is to asking
Problem listed by topic table is clearly answered, after the test paper coordinated person induction-arrangement of results and analysis, then by result with letters
Form be sent to expert.But, expert opinion may not necessarily reflect objective reality, and the responsibility of each expert is more disperseed, and estimates
The flexible strategy of meter should not determine, therefore, is normally only applicable to the prediction of total value, and reliable when region, customer base, product category
Property is poor.
LEC risk assessment method, full name operation risk analysis method, is a kind of dangerous quantitative calculation method.According to dangerous matter sources
Identification record, the risk that each dangerous matter sources of quantitative Analysis is brought, determine and do Risks, list inventory and issue, planned
Control risk.The computational methods used: D=L × E × C, wherein: D is value-at-risk, L is the probability size having an accident, E
For being exposed to the frequent degree of hazardous environment, C is the consequence produced that has an accident.But, LEC risk assessment method, to danger
The division of grade, is by virtue of experience to judge to a certain extent, has its limitation, and the local that it is a kind of operation is commented during application
Valency, therefore can not generally be suitable for.
Summary of the invention
For the problems referred to above, the present invention provides risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP).
The purpose of the present invention realizes by the following technical solutions:
Risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP), including:
(1) evaluation criteria system generation module, for generating the evaluation criteria system being directed to dangerous matter sources, described evaluation refers to
Mark system is formulated by the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources, and it includes that destination layer, rule layer and indicator layer, described destination layer are defined as treating
The dangerous matter sources of assessment, described rule layer include probability that dangerous matter sources causes danger, dangerous matter sources cause danger after influence degree and
Three female indexs of uncontrollability, described indicator layer includes the every sub-index corresponding to female index, wherein considers that system is taked
Safety measure or strategy are to the abatement of risk and control action, and definition uncontrollability is to make strategy fails after dangerous matter sources is caused danger
Ability characteristics;
(2) opinion rating system generation module, for generating the opinion rating system corresponding to evaluation criteria system, described
Opinion rating system is formulated by the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources, and it includes multiple opinion rating, each opinion rating correspondence one
Individual grade fuzzy subset;
(3) quantification of targets module, for gathering described every sub-index and according to the impact on corresponding female index of the sub-index
Degree quantifies;
(4) index weights computing module, calculates female index and the weight vectors of sub-index for reference level fractional analysis;
(5) subordinated-degree matrix builds module, for according to described evaluation criteria system, calculates dangerous matter sources respectively to described etc.
The degree of membership of level fuzzy subset, builds the subordinated-degree matrix of female index;
(6) fuzzy overall evaluation result computing module, for according to subordinated-degree matrix and weight vector computation fuzzy synthesis
Evaluation result;
(7) risk evaluation module, including risk profiles assessment submodule, risk analysis submodule and risk control submodule
Block, described risk profiles assessment submodule for calculating the wind of destination layer according to weight vectors and fuzzy overall evaluation result vector
Danger degree;Described risk analysis submodule, is analyzed for the risk assessment situation obtaining risk evaluation module, finds risk
Node that propagation path, Risk of Communication ability are stronger and easy infected node also export analysis result;Described risk control
Module, for adjusting the access control policy of network and susceptible node security strategy according to described analysis result, strengthens being felt
The safety management of dye node.
Preferably, described opinion rating includes probability opinion rating, severity ratings grade;Described probability evaluation etc.
It is extremely impossible, rarely possible, possible, quite possible, entirely possible that level includes;Described severity ratings grade include negligible,
Slight, serious, dangerous, disaster.
Preferably, in the described every sub-index corresponding to female index, corresponding to the son of the probability that dangerous matter sources is caused danger
Index includes threatening motivation, attacking ability, attack complexity, vulnerability exploit rate and assets captivation, occurs corresponding to dangerous matter sources
The sub-index of the influence degree after danger includes confidentiality impact, integrity impact, availability impact and relatedness impact, corresponding
Sub-index in uncontrollability includes disguised power of test, multiformity power of test and prominent anti-defensive ability/resistance ability.
Wherein, specifically perform during the running of described quantification of targets module:
If P, D, C represent respectively probability that dangerous matter sources causes danger, dangerous matter sources cause danger after influence degree and can not
Control property, the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources carries out, to the quantized value of the sub-index of x-th of female index y, the quantized value that n evaluation obtains
Collection isThe final quantization value of the sub-index of x-th of female index y is:
Wherein, described subordinated-degree matrix builds module when calculating dangerous matter sources to the degree of membership of described grade fuzzy subset, tool
Body operates below performing:
Definition grade fuzzy subset is { vj, j=1,2 ..., 5}, and define the influence degree equity for describing female index
The membership function of the degree of membership of level fuzzy subset:
Wherein, ρ is the final quantization of the sub-index of x-th of female index y determined by the expert group expert evaluating dangerous matter sources
Value,For grade fuzzy subset { vj, j=1,2 ..., standard value corresponding for 5},μ is to evaluate dangerous matter sources
Expert group's certainty factor to described final quantization value;
According to described membership function, construct P, the subordinated-degree matrix R of tri-female indexs of D, C respectivelyP,RD,RC:
Wherein, NPRepresent the sub-index number that female index P comprises, NDRepresent the sub-index number that female index D comprises, NCTable
Show the sub-index number that female index C comprises;
Wherein, the computing formula of described fuzzy overall evaluation result computing module calculating fuzzy overall evaluation result M is:
Wherein, if the weight fuzzy subset corresponding to female index P obtained according to weight vectors, D, C is W={ wP,wD,
wC, the weight fuzzy subset corresponding to sub-index set under female index P of obtaining according to weight vectors, D, C is respectively mP、mD、
mC, * represents that generalized fuzzy synthesizes computing;
Wherein, when calculating described risk, if grade corresponding to grade fuzzy subset is entered as { Hj, j=1,2 .., 5},
I.e. grade vjCorresponding numerical value Hj, and grade vjFrom low paramount time described HjValue is incremented by, and the computing formula of described risk FD is:
The invention have the benefit that
(1) risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP), is existed by fuzzy matrix and analytic hierarchy process (AHP)
Application in risk assessment, can be analyzed the various uncertain factors, the index that occur during risk assessment;
(2) membership function of the degree of membership of influence degree In Grade fuzzy subset for describing female index is defined, and
Utilize described membership function to carry out subordinated-degree matrix structure, calculated degree of membership Normal Distribution, more conformed to reality, kept away
Exempt from the impact of artificial subjective factor, enhance the objectivity of assessment result;
(3) proposing the computing formula of fuzzy overall evaluation result and risk, this computing formula is examined the most all sidedly
Consider the factor affecting risk, highlighted the impact of safety measure Usefulness Pair systematic risk degree, it is achieved that the thing to dangerous matter sources
Later evaluation.
Accompanying drawing explanation
The invention will be further described to utilize accompanying drawing, but the embodiment in accompanying drawing does not constitute any limit to the present invention
System, for those of ordinary skill in the art, on the premise of not paying creative work, it is also possible to obtain according to the following drawings
Other accompanying drawing.
Fig. 1 is the connection diagram of each module of the present invention;
Fig. 2 is the structural representation of risk evaluation module of the present invention.
Reference:
Evaluation criteria system generation module 1, opinion rating system generation module 2, quantification of targets module 3, index weights meter
Calculate module 4, subordinated-degree matrix builds module 5, fuzzy overall evaluation result computing module 6, risk evaluation module 7, risk profiles
Assessment submodule 71, risk analysis submodule 72, risk control submodule 73.
Detailed description of the invention
The invention will be further described with the following Examples.
Embodiment 1
See Fig. 1, Fig. 2, the present embodiment risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP), including:
(1) evaluation criteria system generation module 1, for generating the evaluation criteria system being directed to dangerous matter sources, described evaluation
Index system is formulated by the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources, and it includes that destination layer, rule layer and indicator layer, described destination layer are defined as
Dangerous matter sources to be assessed, described rule layer include probability that dangerous matter sources causes danger, dangerous matter sources cause danger after influence degree
With three female indexs of uncontrollability, described indicator layer includes the every sub-index corresponding to female index, wherein considers that system is adopted
Taking safety measure or strategy to the abatement of risk and control action, definition uncontrollability is to make strategy mistake after dangerous matter sources is caused danger
The ability characteristics of effect;
(2) opinion rating system generation module 2, for generating the opinion rating system corresponding to evaluation criteria system, institute
Commentary valency hierarchical system is formulated by the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources, and it includes multiple opinion rating, and each opinion rating is corresponding
One grade fuzzy subset;
(3) quantification of targets module 3, for gathering described every sub-index and according to the impact on corresponding female index of the sub-index
Degree quantifies;
(4) index weights computing module 4, calculates female index and the weight vectors of sub-index for reference level fractional analysis;
(5) subordinated-degree matrix builds module 5, for according to described evaluation criteria system, calculates dangerous matter sources respectively to described
The degree of membership of grade fuzzy subset, builds the subordinated-degree matrix of female index;
(6) fuzzy overall evaluation result computing module 6, for according to subordinated-degree matrix and weight vector computation fuzzy synthesis
Evaluation result;
(7) risk evaluation module 7, including risk profiles assessment submodule 71, risk analysis submodule 72 and risk control
Submodule 73, described risk profiles assessment submodule 71 is for calculating mesh according to weight vectors and fuzzy overall evaluation result vector
The risk of mark layer;Described risk analysis submodule 72, is carried out point for the risk assessment situation that obtains risk evaluation module
Analysis, finds node that Risk of Communication path, Risk of Communication ability are stronger and easy infected node and exports analysis result;Described
Risk control submodule 73, for adjusting the access control policy of network and susceptible node security plan according to described analysis result
Slightly, the safety management of the most infected node is strengthened.
The present embodiment risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP), by fuzzy matrix and step analysis
Method application in risk assessment, can be analyzed the various uncertain factors, the index that occur during risk assessment.
Embodiment 2
See Fig. 1, Fig. 2, the present embodiment risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP), including:
(1) evaluation criteria system generation module 1, for generating the evaluation criteria system being directed to dangerous matter sources, described evaluation
Index system is formulated by the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources, and it includes that destination layer, rule layer and indicator layer, described destination layer are defined as
Dangerous matter sources to be assessed, described rule layer include probability that dangerous matter sources causes danger, dangerous matter sources cause danger after influence degree
With three female indexs of uncontrollability, described indicator layer includes the every sub-index corresponding to female index, wherein considers that system is adopted
Taking safety measure or strategy to the abatement of risk and control action, definition uncontrollability is to make strategy mistake after dangerous matter sources is caused danger
The ability characteristics of effect;
(2) opinion rating system generation module 2, for generating the opinion rating system corresponding to evaluation criteria system, institute
Commentary valency hierarchical system is formulated by the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources, and it includes multiple opinion rating, and each opinion rating is corresponding
One grade fuzzy subset;
(3) quantification of targets module 3, for gathering described every sub-index and according to the impact on corresponding female index of the sub-index
Degree quantifies, and specifically performs during the running of described quantification of targets module:
If P, D, C represent respectively probability that dangerous matter sources causes danger, dangerous matter sources cause danger after influence degree and can not
Control property, the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources carries out, to the quantized value of the sub-index of x-th of female index y, the quantized value that n evaluation obtains
Collection isThe final quantization value of the sub-index of x-th of female index y is:
(4) index weights computing module 4, calculates female index and the weight vectors of sub-index for reference level fractional analysis;
(5) subordinated-degree matrix builds module 5, for according to described evaluation criteria system, calculates dangerous matter sources respectively to described
The degree of membership of grade fuzzy subset, builds the subordinated-degree matrix of female index, and wherein, described subordinated-degree matrix builds module 5 and calculates
When dangerous matter sources is to the degree of membership of described grade fuzzy subset, concrete perform following operation:
Definition grade fuzzy subset is { vj, j=1,2 ..., 5}, and define the influence degree equity for describing female index
The membership function of the degree of membership of level fuzzy subset:
Wherein, ρ is the final quantization of the sub-index of x-th of female index y determined by the expert group expert evaluating dangerous matter sources
Value,For grade fuzzy subset { vj, j=1,2 ..., 5 } corresponding standard value,μ is to evaluate dangerous matter sources
Expert group's certainty factor to described final quantization value;
According to described membership function, construct P, the subordinated-degree matrix R of tri-female indexs of D, C respectivelyP,RD,RC:
Wherein, NPRepresent the sub-index number that female index P comprises, NDRepresent the sub-index number that female index D comprises, NCTable
Show the sub-index number that female index C comprises;
(6) fuzzy overall evaluation result computing module 6, for according to subordinated-degree matrix and weight vector computation fuzzy synthesis
Evaluation result;
(7) risk evaluation module 7, including risk profiles assessment submodule 71, risk analysis submodule 72 and risk control
Submodule 73, described risk profiles assessment submodule 71 is for calculating mesh according to weight vectors and fuzzy overall evaluation result vector
The risk of mark layer;Described risk analysis submodule 72, is carried out point for the risk assessment situation that obtains risk evaluation module
Analysis, finds node that Risk of Communication path, Risk of Communication ability are stronger and easy infected node and exports analysis result;Described
Risk control submodule 73, for adjusting the access control policy of network and susceptible node security plan according to described analysis result
Slightly, the safety management of the most infected node is strengthened.
What the present embodiment defined the degree of membership of the influence degree In Grade fuzzy subset for describing female index is subordinate to letter
Number, and utilize described membership function to carry out subordinated-degree matrix structure, calculate degree of membership Normal Distribution, more conform to reality
Border, it is to avoid the impact of artificial subjective factor, enhances the objectivity of assessment result.
Embodiment 3
See Fig. 1, Fig. 2, the present embodiment risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP), including:
(1) evaluation criteria system generation module 1, for generating the evaluation criteria system being directed to dangerous matter sources, described evaluation
Index system is formulated by the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources, and it includes that destination layer, rule layer and indicator layer, described destination layer are defined as
Dangerous matter sources to be assessed, described rule layer include probability that dangerous matter sources causes danger, dangerous matter sources cause danger after influence degree
With three female indexs of uncontrollability, described indicator layer includes the every sub-index corresponding to female index, wherein considers that system is adopted
Taking safety measure or strategy to the abatement of risk and control action, definition uncontrollability is to make strategy mistake after dangerous matter sources is caused danger
The ability characteristics of effect;
(2) opinion rating system generation module 2, for generating the opinion rating system corresponding to evaluation criteria system, institute
Commentary valency hierarchical system is formulated by the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources, and it includes multiple opinion rating, and each opinion rating is corresponding
One grade fuzzy subset;
(3) quantification of targets module 3, for gathering described every sub-index and according to the impact on corresponding female index of the sub-index
Degree quantifies, and specifically performs during the running of described quantification of targets module:
If P, D, C represent respectively probability that dangerous matter sources causes danger, dangerous matter sources cause danger after influence degree and can not
Control property, the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources carries out, to the quantized value of the sub-index of x-th of female index y, the quantized value that n evaluation obtains
Collection isThe final quantization value of the sub-index of x-th of female index y is:
(4) index weights computing module 4, calculates female index and the weight vectors of sub-index for reference level fractional analysis;
(5) subordinated-degree matrix builds module 5, for according to described evaluation criteria system, calculates dangerous matter sources respectively to described
The degree of membership of grade fuzzy subset, builds the subordinated-degree matrix of female index, and wherein, described subordinated-degree matrix builds module 5 and calculates
When dangerous matter sources is to the degree of membership of described grade fuzzy subset, concrete perform following operation:
Definition grade fuzzy subset is { vj, j=1,2 ..., 5 }, and define the influence degree equity for describing female index
The membership function of the degree of membership of level fuzzy subset:
Wherein, ρ is the final quantization of the sub-index of x-th of female index y determined by the expert group expert evaluating dangerous matter sources
Value,For grade fuzzy subset { vj, j=1,2 ..., standard value corresponding for 5},μ is to evaluate dangerous matter sources
Expert group's certainty factor to described final quantization value;
According to described membership function, construct P, the subordinated-degree matrix R of tri-female indexs of D, C respectivelyP,RD,RC:
Wherein, NPRepresent the sub-index number that female index P comprises, NDRepresent the sub-index number that female index D comprises, NCTable
Show the sub-index number that female index C comprises;
(6) fuzzy overall evaluation result computing module 6, for according to subordinated-degree matrix and weight vector computation fuzzy synthesis
Evaluation result, wherein, the computing formula that described fuzzy overall evaluation result computing module 6 calculates fuzzy overall evaluation result M is:
Wherein, if the weight fuzzy subset corresponding to female index P obtained according to weight vectors, D, C is W={ wP,wD,
wC, the weight fuzzy subset corresponding to sub-index set under female index P of obtaining according to weight vectors, D, C is respectively mP、mD、
mC, * represents that generalized fuzzy synthesizes computing;
(7) risk evaluation module 7, including risk profiles assessment submodule 71, risk analysis submodule 72 and risk control
Submodule 73, described risk profiles assessment submodule 71 is for calculating mesh according to weight vectors and fuzzy overall evaluation result vector
The risk of mark layer;Described risk analysis submodule 72, is carried out point for the risk assessment situation that obtains risk evaluation module
Analysis, finds node that Risk of Communication path, Risk of Communication ability are stronger and easy infected node and exports analysis result;Described
Risk control submodule 73, for adjusting the access control policy of network and susceptible node security plan according to described analysis result
Slightly, the safety management of the most infected node is strengthened.
Wherein, when calculating described risk, if grade corresponding to grade fuzzy subset is entered as { Hj, j=1,2 .., 5 },
I.e. grade vjCorresponding numerical value Hj, and grade vjFrom low paramount time described HjValue is incremented by, and the computing formula of described risk FD is:
What the present embodiment defined the degree of membership of the influence degree In Grade fuzzy subset for describing female index is subordinate to letter
Number, and utilize described membership function to carry out subordinated-degree matrix structure, calculate degree of membership Normal Distribution, more conform to reality
Border, it is to avoid the impact of artificial subjective factor, enhances the objectivity of assessment result;Propose fuzzy overall evaluation result and wind
The computing formula of danger degree, this computing formula considers the factor affecting risk the most all sidedly, highlights safety measure effective
The property impact on systematic risk degree, it is achieved that the after-action review to dangerous matter sources.
Embodiment 4
(1) evaluation criteria system generation module 1, for generating the evaluation criteria system being directed to dangerous matter sources, described evaluation
Index system is formulated by the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources, and it includes that destination layer, rule layer and indicator layer, described destination layer are defined as
Dangerous matter sources to be assessed, described rule layer include probability that dangerous matter sources causes danger, dangerous matter sources cause danger after influence degree
With three female indexs of uncontrollability, described indicator layer includes the every sub-index corresponding to female index, wherein considers that system is adopted
Taking safety measure or strategy to the abatement of risk and control action, definition uncontrollability is to make strategy mistake after dangerous matter sources is caused danger
The ability characteristics of effect;
(2) opinion rating system generation module 2, for generating the opinion rating system corresponding to evaluation criteria system, institute
Commentary valency hierarchical system is formulated by the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources, and it includes multiple opinion rating, and each opinion rating is corresponding
One grade fuzzy subset;
(3) quantification of targets module 3, for gathering described every sub-index and according to the impact on corresponding female index of the sub-index
Degree quantifies, and specifically performs during the running of described quantification of targets module:
If P, D, C represent respectively probability that dangerous matter sources causes danger, dangerous matter sources cause danger after influence degree and can not
Control property, the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources carries out, to the quantized value of the sub-index of x-th of female index y, the quantized value that n evaluation obtains
Collection isThe final quantization value of the sub-index of x-th of female index y is:
(4) index weights computing module 4, calculates female index and the weight vectors of sub-index for reference level fractional analysis;
(5) subordinated-degree matrix builds module 5, for according to described evaluation criteria system, calculates dangerous matter sources respectively to described
The degree of membership of grade fuzzy subset, builds the subordinated-degree matrix of female index, and wherein, described subordinated-degree matrix builds module 5 and calculates
When dangerous matter sources is to the degree of membership of described grade fuzzy subset, concrete perform following operation:
Definition grade fuzzy subset is { vj, j=1,2 ..., 5 }, and define the influence degree equity for describing female index
The membership function of the degree of membership of level fuzzy subset:
Wherein, ρ is the final quantization of the sub-index of x-th of female index y determined by the expert group expert evaluating dangerous matter sources
Value,For grade fuzzy subset { vj, j=1,2 ..., standard value corresponding for 5},μ is the special of evaluation dangerous matter sources
Family's group certainty factor to described final quantization value;
According to described membership function, construct P, the subordinated-degree matrix R of tri-female indexs of D, C respectivelyP,RD,RC:
Wherein, NPRepresent the sub-index number that female index P comprises, NDRepresent the sub-index number that female index D comprises, NCTable
Show the sub-index number that female index C comprises;
(6) fuzzy overall evaluation result computing module 6, for according to subordinated-degree matrix and weight vector computation fuzzy synthesis
Evaluation result, wherein, the computing formula that described fuzzy overall evaluation result computing module 6 calculates fuzzy overall evaluation result M is:
Wherein, if the weight fuzzy subset corresponding to female index P obtained according to weight vectors, D, C is W={wP,wD,
wC, the weight fuzzy subset corresponding to sub-index set under female index P of obtaining according to weight vectors, D, C is respectively mP、mD、
mC, * represents that generalized fuzzy synthesizes computing;
(7) risk evaluation module 7, including risk profiles assessment submodule 71, risk analysis submodule 72 and risk control
Submodule 73, described risk profiles assessment submodule 71 is for calculating mesh according to weight vectors and fuzzy overall evaluation result vector
The risk of mark layer;Described risk analysis submodule 72, is carried out point for the risk assessment situation that obtains risk evaluation module
Analysis, finds node that Risk of Communication path, Risk of Communication ability are stronger and easy infected node and exports analysis result;Described
Risk control submodule 73, for adjusting the access control policy of network and susceptible node security plan according to described analysis result
Slightly, the safety management of the most infected node is strengthened.
Wherein, when calculating described risk, if grade corresponding to grade fuzzy subset is entered as { Hj, j=1,2 .., 5},
I.e. grade vjCorresponding numerical value Hj, and grade vjFrom low paramount time described HjValue is incremented by, and the computing formula of described risk FD is:
Wherein, described opinion rating includes probability opinion rating, severity ratings grade;Described probability opinion rating
Including extremely impossible, rarely possible, possible, quite possible, entirely possible;Described severity ratings grade includes negligible, light
Micro-, serious, dangerous, disaster.
What the present embodiment defined the degree of membership of the influence degree In Grade fuzzy subset for describing female index is subordinate to letter
Number, and utilize described membership function to carry out subordinated-degree matrix structure, calculate degree of membership Normal Distribution, more conform to reality
Border, it is to avoid the impact of artificial subjective factor, enhances the objectivity of assessment result;Propose fuzzy overall evaluation result and wind
The computing formula of danger degree, this computing formula considers the factor affecting risk the most all sidedly, highlights safety measure effective
The property impact on systematic risk degree, it is achieved that the after-action review to dangerous matter sources, and define the content of opinion rating, improve
The completeness of risk evaluating system.
Embodiment 5
(1) evaluation criteria system generation module 1, for generating the evaluation criteria system being directed to dangerous matter sources, described evaluation
Index system is formulated by the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources, and it includes that destination layer, rule layer and indicator layer, described destination layer are defined as
Dangerous matter sources to be assessed, described rule layer include probability that dangerous matter sources causes danger, dangerous matter sources cause danger after influence degree
With three female indexs of uncontrollability, described indicator layer includes the every sub-index corresponding to female index, wherein considers that system is adopted
Taking safety measure or strategy to the abatement of risk and control action, definition uncontrollability is to make strategy mistake after dangerous matter sources is caused danger
The ability characteristics of effect;
(2) opinion rating system generation module 2, for generating the opinion rating system corresponding to evaluation criteria system, institute
Commentary valency hierarchical system is formulated by the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources, and it includes multiple opinion rating, and each opinion rating is corresponding
One grade fuzzy subset;
(3) quantification of targets module 3, for gathering described every sub-index and according to the impact on corresponding female index of the sub-index
Degree quantifies, and specifically performs during the running of described quantification of targets module:
If P, D, C represent respectively probability that dangerous matter sources causes danger, dangerous matter sources cause danger after influence degree and can not
Control property, the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources carries out, to the quantized value of the sub-index of x-th of female index y, the quantized value that n evaluation obtains
Collection isThe final quantization value of the sub-index of x-th of female index y is:
(4) index weights computing module 4, calculates female index and the weight vectors of sub-index for reference level fractional analysis;
(5) subordinated-degree matrix builds module 5, for according to described evaluation criteria system, calculates dangerous matter sources respectively to described
The degree of membership of grade fuzzy subset, builds the subordinated-degree matrix of female index, and wherein, described subordinated-degree matrix builds module 5 and calculates
When dangerous matter sources is to the degree of membership of described grade fuzzy subset, concrete perform following operation:
Definition grade fuzzy subset is { vj, j=1,2 ..., 5}, and define the influence degree equity for describing female index
The membership function of the degree of membership of level fuzzy subset:
Wherein, ρ is the final quantization of the sub-index of x-th of female index y determined by the expert group expert evaluating dangerous matter sources
Value,For grade fuzzy subset { vj, j=1,2 ..., standard value corresponding for 5},μ is to evaluate dangerous matter sources
Expert group's certainty factor to described final quantization value;
According to described membership function, construct P, the subordinated-degree matrix R of tri-female indexs of D, C respectivelyP,RD,RC:
Wherein, NPRepresent the sub-index number that female index P comprises, NDRepresent the sub-index number that female index D comprises, NCTable
Show the sub-index number that female index C comprises;
(6) fuzzy overall evaluation result computing module 6, for according to subordinated-degree matrix and weight vector computation fuzzy synthesis
Evaluation result, wherein, the computing formula that described fuzzy overall evaluation result computing module 6 calculates fuzzy overall evaluation result M is:
Wherein, if the weight fuzzy subset corresponding to female index P obtained according to weight vectors, D, C is W={wP,wD,
wC, the weight fuzzy subset corresponding to sub-index set under female index P of obtaining according to weight vectors, D, C is respectively mP、mD、
mC, * represents that generalized fuzzy synthesizes computing;
(7) risk evaluation module 7, including risk profiles assessment submodule 71, risk analysis submodule 72 and risk control
Submodule 73, described risk profiles assessment submodule 71 is for calculating mesh according to weight vectors and fuzzy overall evaluation result vector
The risk of mark layer;Described risk analysis submodule 72, is carried out point for the risk assessment situation that obtains risk evaluation module
Analysis, finds node that Risk of Communication path, Risk of Communication ability are stronger and easy infected node and exports analysis result;Described
Risk control submodule 73, for adjusting the access control policy of network and susceptible node security plan according to described analysis result
Slightly, the safety management of the most infected node is strengthened.
Wherein, when calculating described risk, if grade corresponding to grade fuzzy subset is entered as { Hj, j=1,2 .., 5},
I.e. grade vjCorresponding numerical value Hj, and grade vjFrom low paramount time described HjValue is incremented by, and the computing formula of described risk FD is:
Wherein, described opinion rating includes probability opinion rating, severity ratings grade;Described probability opinion rating
Including extremely impossible, rarely possible, possible, quite possible, entirely possible;Described severity ratings grade includes negligible, light
Micro-, serious, dangerous, disaster.
Wherein, in the described every sub-index corresponding to female index, the son of the probability caused danger corresponding to dangerous matter sources refers to
Mark includes threatening motivation, attacking ability, attack complexity, vulnerability exploit rate and assets captivation, endangers corresponding to dangerous matter sources
The sub-index of the influence degree behind danger includes confidentiality impact, integrity impact, availability impact and relatedness impact, corresponds to
The sub-index of uncontrollability includes disguised power of test, multiformity power of test and prominent anti-defensive ability/resistance ability.
What the present embodiment defined the degree of membership of the influence degree In Grade fuzzy subset for describing female index is subordinate to letter
Number, and utilize described membership function to carry out subordinated-degree matrix structure, calculate degree of membership Normal Distribution, more conform to reality
Border, it is to avoid the impact of artificial subjective factor, enhances the objectivity of assessment result;Propose fuzzy overall evaluation result and wind
The computing formula of danger degree, this computing formula considers the factor affecting risk the most all sidedly, highlights safety measure effective
The property impact on systematic risk degree, it is achieved that the after-action review to dangerous matter sources, and define opinion rating and every sub-index
Content, improve the completeness of risk evaluating system.
Last it should be noted that, above example is only in order to illustrate technical scheme, rather than the present invention is protected
Protecting the restriction of scope, although having made to explain to the present invention with reference to preferred embodiment, those of ordinary skill in the art should
Work as understanding, technical scheme can be modified or equivalent, without deviating from the reality of technical solution of the present invention
Matter and scope.
Claims (7)
1. risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP), it is characterised in that including:
(1) evaluation criteria system generation module, for generating the evaluation criteria system being directed to dangerous matter sources, described evaluation index system
Uniting and formulated by the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources, it includes that destination layer, rule layer and indicator layer, described destination layer are defined as to be assessed
Dangerous matter sources, described rule layer include probability that dangerous matter sources causes danger, dangerous matter sources cause danger after influence degree and can not
Three female indexs of control property, described indicator layer includes the every sub-index corresponding to female index, wherein considers the taked safety of system
Measure or strategy are to the abatement of risk and control action, and definition uncontrollability is to make the energy of strategy fails after dangerous matter sources is caused danger
Force characteristic;
(2) opinion rating system generation module, for generating the opinion rating system corresponding to evaluation criteria system, described evaluation
Hierarchical system is formulated by the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources, and it includes multiple opinion rating, corresponding one of each opinion rating etc.
Level fuzzy subset;
(3) quantification of targets module, for gathering described every sub-index and according to the sub-index influence degree to corresponding female index
Quantify;
(4) index weights computing module, calculates female index and the weight vectors of sub-index for reference level fractional analysis;
(5) subordinated-degree matrix builds module, for according to described evaluation criteria system, calculates dangerous matter sources respectively to described grade mould
Stick with paste the degree of membership of subset, build the subordinated-degree matrix of female index;
(6) fuzzy overall evaluation result computing module, for according to subordinated-degree matrix and weight vector computation fuzzy overall evaluation
Result;
(7) risk evaluation module, including risk profiles assessment submodule, risk analysis submodule and risk control submodule, institute
State risk profiles assessment submodule for calculating the risk of destination layer according to weight vectors and fuzzy overall evaluation result vector;
Described risk analysis submodule, is analyzed for the risk assessment situation obtaining risk evaluation module, finds Risk of Communication
Node that path, Risk of Communication ability are stronger and easy infected node also export analysis result;Described risk control submodule,
For adjusting the access control policy of network and susceptible node security strategy according to described analysis result, strengthen the most infected node
Safety management.
Risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP) the most according to claim 1, it is characterised in that described
Opinion rating includes probability opinion rating, severity ratings grade;Described probability opinion rating includes extremely impossible, few
Possible, possible, quite possible, entirely possible;Described severity ratings grade includes negligible, slight, serious, dangerous
, disaster.
Risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP) the most according to claim 1, it is characterised in that described
In every sub-index corresponding to female index, the sub-index of the probability caused danger corresponding to dangerous matter sources includes threatening motivation, attacking
Hit ability, attack complexity, vulnerability exploit rate and assets captivation, the son of the influence degree after causing danger corresponding to dangerous matter sources
Index includes confidentiality impact, integrity impact, availability impact and relatedness impact, corresponding to the sub-index of uncontrollability
Including disguised power of test, multiformity power of test and prominent anti-defensive ability/resistance ability.
Risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP) the most according to claim 1, it is characterised in that described
Specifically perform during the running of quantification of targets module:
If P, D, C represent respectively probability that dangerous matter sources causes danger, dangerous matter sources cause danger after influence degree and uncontrollability,
The quantized value of the sub-index of x-th of female index y is carried out n time evaluating the set of quantized obtained by the expert group of evaluation dangerous matter sourcesY=P, D, C, the final quantization value of the sub-index of x-th of female index y is:
。
Risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP) the most according to claim 4, it is characterised in that described
Subordinated-degree matrix builds module when calculating dangerous matter sources to the degree of membership of described grade fuzzy subset, concrete performs following operation:
Definition grade fuzzy subset is { vj, j=1,2 ..., 5}, and define the influence degree In Grade mould for describing female index
The membership function of the degree of membership of paste subset:
Wherein, ρ is the final quantization value of the sub-index of x-th of the female index y determined by the expert group expert evaluating dangerous matter sources,
For grade fuzzy subset { vj, j=1,2 ..., standard value corresponding for 5},μ is the expert group evaluating dangerous matter sources
Certainty factor to described final quantization value;
According to described membership function, construct P, the subordinated-degree matrix R of tri-female indexs of D, C respectivelyP,RD,RC:
Wherein, NPRepresent the sub-index number that female index P comprises, NDRepresent the sub-index number that female index D comprises, NCRepresent mother
The sub-index number that index C comprises.
Risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP) the most according to claim 5, it is characterised in that described
Fuzzy overall evaluation result computing module calculates the computing formula of fuzzy overall evaluation result M:
Wherein, if the weight fuzzy subset corresponding to female index P obtained according to weight vectors, D, C is W={wP,wD,wC, root
The weight fuzzy subset corresponding to sub-index set under female index P of obtaining according to weight vectors, D, C is respectively mP、mD、mC, * table
Show that generalized fuzzy synthesizes computing.
Risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP) the most according to claim 6, it is characterised in that calculate
During described risk, if grade corresponding to grade fuzzy subset is entered as { Hj, j=1,2 .., 5}, i.e. grade vjCorresponding numerical value
Hj, and grade vjFrom low paramount time described HjValue is incremented by, and the computing formula of described risk FD is:
Priority Applications (1)
| Application Number | Priority Date | Filing Date | Title |
|---|---|---|---|
| CN201610541641.7A CN106230773A (en) | 2016-07-05 | 2016-07-05 | Risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP) |
Applications Claiming Priority (1)
| Application Number | Priority Date | Filing Date | Title |
|---|---|---|---|
| CN201610541641.7A CN106230773A (en) | 2016-07-05 | 2016-07-05 | Risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP) |
Publications (1)
| Publication Number | Publication Date |
|---|---|
| CN106230773A true CN106230773A (en) | 2016-12-14 |
Family
ID=57519516
Family Applications (1)
| Application Number | Title | Priority Date | Filing Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| CN201610541641.7A Withdrawn CN106230773A (en) | 2016-07-05 | 2016-07-05 | Risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP) |
Country Status (1)
| Country | Link |
|---|---|
| CN (1) | CN106230773A (en) |
Cited By (14)
| Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CN106777848A (en) * | 2017-03-29 | 2017-05-31 | 辽宁工程技术大学 | A kind of arch rib lifting construction method for estimating stability based on fuzzy overall evaluation |
| CN107231345A (en) * | 2017-05-03 | 2017-10-03 | 成都国腾实业集团有限公司 | Networks congestion control methods of risk assessment based on AHP |
| CN108023781A (en) * | 2017-12-26 | 2018-05-11 | 上海仪电物联技术股份有限公司 | A kind of method that risk to IP network change is analyzed |
| CN108108890A (en) * | 2017-12-18 | 2018-06-01 | 北京航空航天大学 | A kind of defective workmanship risk analysis method based on process incidence relation |
| CN108345975A (en) * | 2017-01-24 | 2018-07-31 | 中国石油化工股份有限公司 | A kind of oil depot Failure risk evaluation method and device |
| CN108575497A (en) * | 2018-04-02 | 2018-09-28 | 河海大学 | A kind of seeds sampling method of the rigid forest against wave wash based on fuzzy matter element |
| CN109040655A (en) * | 2018-09-03 | 2018-12-18 | 徐兴年 | A kind of video conferencing system based on information network |
| CN109034286A (en) * | 2018-05-22 | 2018-12-18 | 广东工业大学 | Based on BIM and RFID construction risk source identification and management method |
| CN109359894A (en) * | 2018-11-29 | 2019-02-19 | 武汉大学 | A method and device for risk assessment of power metering equipment based on RPN |
| CN111143763A (en) * | 2019-12-13 | 2020-05-12 | 广东电网有限责任公司 | Method and device for evaluating state of power equipment and storage medium thereof |
| CN111641596A (en) * | 2020-05-11 | 2020-09-08 | 湖南大学 | Power network information physical potential safety hazard assessment method and system and power system |
| CN112039211A (en) * | 2020-09-07 | 2020-12-04 | 国网四川省电力公司电力科学研究院 | Optimization method for reliability and complexity of secondary security measures in smart substations |
| CN112702345A (en) * | 2020-12-24 | 2021-04-23 | 福建技术师范学院 | Information vulnerability risk assessment method and device based on data element characteristics |
| CN115034646A (en) * | 2022-06-23 | 2022-09-09 | 中国人民武装警察部队警官学院 | A Risk Propagation Source Control Method for Complex Tasks |
-
2016
- 2016-07-05 CN CN201610541641.7A patent/CN106230773A/en not_active Withdrawn
Cited By (20)
| Publication number | Priority date | Publication date | Assignee | Title |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CN108345975A (en) * | 2017-01-24 | 2018-07-31 | 中国石油化工股份有限公司 | A kind of oil depot Failure risk evaluation method and device |
| CN106777848A (en) * | 2017-03-29 | 2017-05-31 | 辽宁工程技术大学 | A kind of arch rib lifting construction method for estimating stability based on fuzzy overall evaluation |
| CN107231345A (en) * | 2017-05-03 | 2017-10-03 | 成都国腾实业集团有限公司 | Networks congestion control methods of risk assessment based on AHP |
| CN108108890A (en) * | 2017-12-18 | 2018-06-01 | 北京航空航天大学 | A kind of defective workmanship risk analysis method based on process incidence relation |
| CN108108890B (en) * | 2017-12-18 | 2021-12-03 | 北京航空航天大学 | Process defect risk analysis method based on process incidence relation |
| CN108023781A (en) * | 2017-12-26 | 2018-05-11 | 上海仪电物联技术股份有限公司 | A kind of method that risk to IP network change is analyzed |
| CN108575497A (en) * | 2018-04-02 | 2018-09-28 | 河海大学 | A kind of seeds sampling method of the rigid forest against wave wash based on fuzzy matter element |
| CN109034286A (en) * | 2018-05-22 | 2018-12-18 | 广东工业大学 | Based on BIM and RFID construction risk source identification and management method |
| CN109040655A (en) * | 2018-09-03 | 2018-12-18 | 徐兴年 | A kind of video conferencing system based on information network |
| CN109040655B (en) * | 2018-09-03 | 2021-03-23 | 科大乾延科技有限公司 | Video conference system based on information network |
| CN109359894A (en) * | 2018-11-29 | 2019-02-19 | 武汉大学 | A method and device for risk assessment of power metering equipment based on RPN |
| CN109359894B (en) * | 2018-11-29 | 2021-07-06 | 武汉大学 | A method and device for risk assessment of power metering equipment based on RPN |
| CN111143763A (en) * | 2019-12-13 | 2020-05-12 | 广东电网有限责任公司 | Method and device for evaluating state of power equipment and storage medium thereof |
| CN111143763B (en) * | 2019-12-13 | 2021-09-17 | 广东电网有限责任公司 | Method and device for evaluating state of power equipment and storage medium thereof |
| CN111641596A (en) * | 2020-05-11 | 2020-09-08 | 湖南大学 | Power network information physical potential safety hazard assessment method and system and power system |
| CN111641596B (en) * | 2020-05-11 | 2021-08-20 | 湖南大学 | Method, system and power system for assessing hidden dangers of cyber-physical security of power network |
| CN112039211A (en) * | 2020-09-07 | 2020-12-04 | 国网四川省电力公司电力科学研究院 | Optimization method for reliability and complexity of secondary security measures in smart substations |
| CN112039211B (en) * | 2020-09-07 | 2022-03-01 | 国网四川省电力公司电力科学研究院 | Optimization method for reliability and complexity of secondary security measures in smart substations |
| CN112702345A (en) * | 2020-12-24 | 2021-04-23 | 福建技术师范学院 | Information vulnerability risk assessment method and device based on data element characteristics |
| CN115034646A (en) * | 2022-06-23 | 2022-09-09 | 中国人民武装警察部队警官学院 | A Risk Propagation Source Control Method for Complex Tasks |
Similar Documents
| Publication | Publication Date | Title |
|---|---|---|
| CN106230773A (en) | Risk evaluating system based on fuzzy matrix analytic hierarchy process (AHP) | |
| Su et al. | Dependence assessment in human reliability analysis using evidence theory and AHP | |
| Chen et al. | Project delivery system selection of construction projects in China | |
| CN106411854B (en) | A kind of network security risk evaluation method based on fuzzy Bayes | |
| CN106101252A (en) | Information Security Risk guard system based on big data and trust computing | |
| CN108881110B (en) | Security situation assessment and defense strategy combined decision method and system | |
| CN107491694B (en) | A Method for Quantitatively Assessing Information Security Vulnerabilities of SCADA Systems | |
| Yang et al. | A new cyber security risk evaluation method for oil and gas SCADA based on factor state space | |
| Liu et al. | A risk assessment method based on RBF artificial neural network-cloud model for urban water hazard | |
| CN106209829A (en) | A kind of network security management system based on warning strategies | |
| CN106227185A (en) | A kind of elevator risk evaluating system | |
| CN118690916A (en) | Power consumption prediction model optimization method and system | |
| CN106203833A (en) | Power telecom network risk evaluating system | |
| CN108446563A (en) | A kind of ICS Method of Information Security Evaluation based on Fuzzy AHP | |
| Salo et al. | Using cross‐impact analysis for probabilistic risk assessment | |
| Babenko et al. | Modeling of the Integrated Quality Assessment System of the Information Security Management System. | |
| CN106060077A (en) | Ocean network security risk assessment system | |
| Li et al. | Aggregation of uncertainty data based on ordered weighting aggregation and generalized information quality | |
| Cheng et al. | Quantitative risk analysis method of information security-Combining fuzzy comprehensive analysis with information entropy | |
| Kotenko et al. | An approach to modeling the decision support process of the security event and incident management based on Markov chains | |
| Zhu et al. | Research on smart home security threat modeling based on STRIDE-IAHP-BN | |
| Kang et al. | Commercial Bank IT Risk Evaluation Model Based on GA-BP Neural Network | |
| CN111768057A (en) | Evaluation method and device of DAS protection effect | |
| CN104834972A (en) | Residential area security state evaluation method based on evidence theory | |
| Lei et al. | Research on ad hoc network security risk assessment method |
Legal Events
| Date | Code | Title | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| C06 | Publication | ||
| PB01 | Publication | ||
| SE01 | Entry into force of request for substantive examination | ||
| SE01 | Entry into force of request for substantive examination | ||
| C04 | Withdrawal of patent application after publication (patent law 2001) | ||
| WW01 | Invention patent application withdrawn after publication |
Application publication date: 20161214 |